MovieChat Forums > Horns (2014) Discussion > I just felt so sorry for Glenna

I just felt so sorry for Glenna


It was a bit glossed over but I just felt so sorry for anyone who had been ignored like that and it had coloured and guided their life in such a way

reply

Same here. A very wounded, tragic, flawed, human character, I thought. Much like Ig. I somewhat related and sympathized/empathized with both (though not being exactly like Glenna, since she has the more "acting out" type personality whereas I'm more shy and quiet, except online lol). Changing your situation is hard. When he asked what was keeping her here and she said "you", I totally understood where she was coming from. Could have seen her and Ig together (and they were together, at least casually romantically and living together, in the book) if he hadn't fallen so much for Merrin first and still been holding a torch for her. The book went into even more detail about Glenna. So yeah, great character. Anyone who'd think of her as cheap, trash, a slut, etc, I think it says more about them than it does about the character.

Plus Kelli Garner isn't hard to look at either...even when pigging out on doughnuts...I wouldn't be able to tell her 'no' either ;-)


"That's the theme of my movies: The victory of the battered idealist in a cynical world."

reply

I have not read the book, but I thought the "Glenna and Ig" storyline was silly and out of place. Iggy and Merrin were together since they were kids, and then as adults Glenna admits being in love with him? Wow....what a waste of a life to be tied to someone who is in love with someone else.

reply

Yup...Glenna loves Ig who loves Merrin. Lee loves Merrin who loves Ig. Merrin says she doesn't love Ig anymore though she really does and is just saying that to try and protect him lol The human heart for ya...ain't love grand? As I said, Glenna was a very human character to me. Maybe it was a wasted life (though if there's one thing I've learned, "wasted life" is a relative term, one person's idea of a wasted life could be a meaningful life to someone else), but I just liked how, when the horns were directed at her, Glenna was never cruel to Ig like everyone (or almost everyone) else was.


"That's the theme of my movies: The victory of the battered idealist in a cynical world."

reply

I hear you, and agree. Just doesn't seem like real life very much.

I mean...if you were dating someone your entire life and felt sick...wouldn't you go with them to the Dr's office? Wouldn't you break the bad news to them on your first phonecall after hearing it from the Dr?

Who just up and runs away because they hear they have cancer? A romantic idea I suppose, but it's definitely not something that happens in real life, I don't think.

X

reply

Fooser, I don't understand half your post very much. I don't think you really understood the situation.

http://www.cgonzales.net & http://www.drxcreatures.com

reply

(Glenna was never cruel to Ig like everyone (or almost everyone) else was.)

Glenna was never a cruel person.

http://www.cgonzales.net & http://www.drxcreatures.com

reply

.

reply

To all who felt sorry for Glenna, if you're a Joe Hill (author) fan, a character that I thought resembled her was Maggie from NOS4A2. Any Maggie fans here? Interested in your thoughts on that character (and I wonder who'd play her in an adaptation). If you're a fan of Glenna, definitely check out the book NOS4A2 for Maggie, too, if you haven't. A minor character all things considered, gets about the same amount of book-time as Glenna in Horns, but very likeable and memorable IMO. Another very flawed, human character like Glenna and Ig.

She's possibly the Joe Hill character I identify with most, so that should tell you all you need to know about me - Pity Sluts unite ;-) Probably not "normal" for a straight dude to identify with a lesbian chick so much, but there you have it lol Just thought she was really cool in her own, quirky, tragic "manic pixie dream girl" kinda way. Also kinda the female equivalent of Stuttering Bill from It (Losers Club ftw)...the apple doesn't fall far from the tree, eh? :-)


"That's the theme of my movies: The victory of the battered idealist in a cynical world."

reply

Yes, I hoped for Ig to survive and that she'd be able to rebuild him, but alas no.

reply

I do feel bad for the movie character because she didn't end up the same way she does in the book. Her ending in the book is much better in my opinion. I'm disappointed that they left that out of the movie!

reply

When she told him the next morning that he'd only made love to her because he was drunk and imagined her to be merrin ..... I thought he could have made sober love to her a second time, sort of thank you sex....he owed her that much.

reply

his girlfriend was just murdered, she didn't want his pity and he horns were growing on his head

not a good time

reply

She was cool as Hell. Anyone who likes giving hand jobs and slamming donuts as much as her is awesome in my book! Plus, she was smoking hot.

"I had my time where I wondered if this was all in my head. That time passed". - Rustin Cohle

reply

Luckily, Iggy talked some sense into her and she's probably gonna take his advice and go off and leave her Podunk town.

When the stars are the only things we share
Will you be there?


-Benjamin Francis Leftwich

reply

U know who really got the *beep* end of the story? Lee.

With how much the left out of Lee's origin, the movie was basically another bland who-done-it. We didn't actually get to see Lee's evolution into how much of a sociopath he is. There was no psyche, and no real motivation. There were so many parts that were left out that made Lee's action make more sense.

reply

None of that was necessary. We knew that he pinned for Merrin and felt so rejected that he snapped.

When the stars are the only things we share
Will you be there?


-Benjamin Francis Leftwich

reply

Um, yeah it was totally necessary. It brought a lot of depth to the character. The backstory prevented him from being just your standard crazy, horny killer.

reply

Then the film wouldn't be a mystery and none of that would have progressed the plot. It wasn't necessary.

When the stars are the only things we share
Will you be there?


-Benjamin Francis Leftwich

reply

In the book, the mystery of who the killer is was solved pretty early on. And it wasn't some startling revelation, it was very nonchalant. Despite the book's plot, finding out who the killer is was less of what it was about

reply

In the book, the mystery of who the killer is was solved pretty early on.


Well this is the ADAPTATION and must be told in ONLY TWO HOURS.

When the stars are the only things we share
Will you be there?


-Benjamin Francis Leftwich

reply

I get that. I'm just proving my point on why Lee's backstory was necessary.

reply

I sort of laughed when every (heterosexual) guy one by one confessed that he loved Merrin, because there were literally only two girls in town. No wonder there were so many dudes who went gay. But, yeah, I also felt sorry for Glenna, though. Only two females in town and no one wanted to have sex with her?

"Enough of that technical talk, Foo!"

reply