MovieChat Forums > The Walking Dead (2010) Discussion > The Key To the Walking Dead Is the Stupi...

The Key To the Walking Dead Is the Stupids


Tonight on THE WALKING DEAD, everyone got stupid. That's nothing new, of course. TWD's writers have made nearly every inch of plot progression in the bulk of the show's run entirely dependent upon and occurring as a consequence of the characters being stupid. Typically not just run-of-the-mill stupid; we're talking profound cretinism so beyond the bounds of credible as to constitute an open, ongoing insult to and mockery of viewers. No one is this Stupid, and no one so unfailingly, relentlessly Stupid would survive very long in a zombie apocalypse. There are other problems with "The Key," tonight's installment, but this is the one that towers over all others.

Savior turncoat Dwight has cast his lot with our heroes. He's accepted that he'll be dead with the current war is over but he wants to help them win before he goes out. Last week, he was forced to return to the Savior fold to protect the denizens of the Safe Zone. A few eps ago, Dwight intentionally led his group of Saviors into an ambush and helped the Alexandrians kill them all, but one, a woman who witnessed his treachery, got away. When he went back to the Saviors last week, he learned that she is still missing in action but he has to figure she's going to turn up at any moment, and then it will be curtains for him. As tonight's ep opens, he's back at his apartment at the Sanctuary and the Stupids kick in really hard; Negan comes to visit him and Dwight doesn't assassinate the villain on sight. He doesn't do it while Negan stands around jawing. Negan is alone and would never see it coming but Dwight let's him talk for a while then leave in peace. Another victory for Negan's plot immunity and not even the only one this evening.

Negan's forces are going to attack Hilltop and Negan has come up with the idea of coating their melee weapons in walker grue in the hope that those cut by them will then die and zombify, so there's a sequence of the Saviors cutting up zombies and getting their knives and axes good and gooey. It's an idea that came from the comics but there, guns and ammo were, by this point, a lot more scarce and fighting with such weapons much more common. Simon barks Negan's orders to the troops: cut some of 'em and make 'em turn but don't kill them all--they're going to go back to work for us when this is over. How, exactly, are the Saviors, who are supposed to be getting low on ammo, ever going to get close enough to cut people barricaded in a walled fortress on a, yes, hilltop, particularly given that those people have guns--fully automatic weapons--to keep any attackers well at bay?...

The full article here:
http://cinemarchaeologist.blogspot.com/2018/03/walking-dead-106.html

reply

It broke new grouuuund!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sLoDsYm8YIQ

reply

I can accept that Dwight was too afraid to attack Negan, even when they were alone. He's very much a beaten-down, fearful beta in the presence of Negan, and fear paralysis didn't seem fake to me.

Meanwhile, Rick is a bad-ass alpha male former policeman (I think I even heard police sirens during his car chase with Negan) who knows his chicken, and yet when he has Negan unconscious, or at the very least woozy, and trapped in an overturned car, rather than walking up and shooting him, he begins blindly shooting at the car's steel undercarriage, giving Negan the chance to flee into the house.

And I agree, that overall, the show is predicated on people acting in ways that people wouldn't act, and doing things that even a dumbass would know better than doing.

reply

(I think I even heard police sirens during his car chase with Negan)

Pretty sure you were just imagining that but that would have been REALLY cool! A better use of the imagination than the writers on this show ever manage.

reply

I heard it too. It's on my tivo, I can confirm later. But the fact that someone else has mentioned this makes me pretty confident there were sirens. Or, maybe coincidentally, we both had police with sirens on going through our neighborhoods while we watched the TWD and exactly at the moment of this chase scene. That would be unbelievable!

reply

Yes, Rick shooting at Negan's car was the biggest rolling of the eyes moment. I can imagine the writers squirming in their seats, having to justify Rick having an automatic weapon, and then quickly erasing his huge advantage, because "we can't kill Negan NOW". It's like the dumbest writer in the room suggested "how about we have Rick waste his bullets trying to shoot him thru the car? He's angry and unfocused, right?", and everyone else agreed because it was either that or completely re-write a couple of passages on a screenplay, or perhaps even re-write the entire scene to have it work more organically. It's like the blind leading the blind.

They wrote Rick with the instincts to duck as he entered the building, but without the brains to go for a kill he could have performed with a rock - Hey, bad guys, I'm over here wildly firing my gun!!!! The writers wrote Rick as an emotionally charged man on a mission with that scene, even giving him 4 different lethal weapons throughout the scene against a (mostly) unarmed man that he absolutely wants dead...and then completely forgot that Rick is a cop.

Right now, I'm imagining Denzel Washington's character in "Man on Fire", and how dead Negan would have been in that scene if THAT character was gunning for him. Counting the times Negan should have been killed has become parody enough that we might as well be watching Robot Chicken sketches of TWD.

Isn't there anybody in that writing room thinking "this scene doesn't fly as is...Negan shouldn't survive this scene...if this confrontation HAS to happen then there's gotta be a better way to set it up". Rick t-boning Negan's car (off screen), and giving Rick two guns (that he might as well have not had) was an awful way to go about it unless Negan was going to die right then and there - Which would have served as a much more organic shock, especially if Simon and Dwight were there to witness it, and let it happen.

reply

Chapeau.

reply

yeah, that kind of stupidity and insulting the dubious though non-zero intelligence of its audience is absolutely infuriating.

reply

Another stupid thing, this time done (regretfully) by Carl - he kept going over the wall into the zombie infested forest my himself. In a place like that he should ALWAYS have someone with him. You would think seven or so years in the zombie apocalypse would have taught him something!!!

reply