The Guy went to India. He is not living with her In the US. He did not stick with the relationship. What she means by "fake" is that he was only a committed partner to her in Second Life. In the "real" world he was not able to stick it out with her.
I liked their arguments... I guess they learned a lot from the experience. They should have kept it online. Kind of sad watching reality rush in on them. They each gave up another relationship for this fantasy.