A bit confusing ... (spoilers)

I thought Nina was David's daughter and the two of them schemed to kill off Alex's mom to get her money which is evil and gross. Otherwise if he's Sara's dad how does he not recognize his own daughter? Either way, it's very confusing.

[deleted]

It's possible I missed something in all of the confusion, but did the movie imply David was the dad of either girl? I just thought he was the boyfriend or husband of their mom, not necessarily their dad. So years later when he thinks Sarah looks familiar, it's possible that when he first met Nina (although we don't see it) he probably thought the same about her too...because they happened to be the little girls of the woman he killed years back.

Shanika
shanikapatrice.com

[deleted]

They were half-sisters. David was Sara's biological father, not Nina's. She said it was disgusting probably because he was the one who killed their mom. She had to have sex with her step-father who murdered her mom. That is still disgusting because she despises him.

David not recognizing both his daughters is def strange. I am still not sure how they expected that one to pass. Because they would have had to stay with him up until they were 18 to leave. Or 16 if they wanted to get emancipated from him. And Sara was supposed to be college age, and Nina 5 years older. So, from 16 or 18 he'd definitely recognize them. So, to just have it make sense for my own sanity--I figure that they realized their father killed their mom. And immediately asked if they could stay with their aunt and live with her shortly after (which was when they were very little) Which I am sure David was cool with because he's obviously a crazy a-hole who kills people, and probably didn't want kids anyway. Especially after all that. So their aunt raised them. And he didn't recognize them because the looked to be about 3 years old and 8 years old. Yes---in real life, he'd probably still recognize at least Nina. But, it's a movie.


The dude 20 bucks to hit on Alex was to form some kind of way of meeting her, geting *some* of her trust--knowing she was a lesbian she knew a drunk guy saying something crude would piss her off, so her jumping in to save her was her entrance into getting Alex to like her, and befriend her. And if you notice, the way she says hello and introduces herself was very flirty. But I don't see how they could have known that would cement the deal, and how they knew Alex would even have it in her to kill anyone. Maybe they were just hoping. A huge plothole is yeah they had this whole plan in motion, but Alex was the one to come up with the murder idea first. How did they know she would be that kind of person and make that sort of plan? Maybe Nina was the one who told Alex to say that to Sara----but if that were the case, the Brooke thing makes no sense. How did they know Brooke would get her fired, get her kicked out of school and housing? Big plothole. Unless someone else can figure that one out for me.