MovieChat Forums > Planet Hulk (2010) Discussion > Bad Adaptation But Entertaining(Spoilers...

Bad Adaptation But Entertaining(Spoilers !!!)


I'm glad I read both the "Planet Hulk" and "World War Hulk" series before I saw this film. Boy did they leave a lot of stuff out. First of all Beta Ray Bill was not in the "Planet Hulk" series, The Silver Surfer was. They both did the same thing though. Hulk also solved the mysteries of the spikes and made them allies. I suggest everyone who saw the film should read both series, they're way better than the movie.

reply

The animated Planet Hulk is the best of the Marvel Animated films. That is not saying much, but story wise, accuracy, character, and animation it is the best overall. The comic story arc Planet Hulk is better. WWH on the other hand is boring. All the heroes who have faced far worse threats suddenly become very stupid and the Hulk is never seriously challenged throughout. Considering all the Hulk endures one wonders how the Sentry burned him out.

reply

I understand that Beta ray bill took the silver surfers place because Sony owns the rights to that character but it did bother me that they choose Bill. Wouldn't he loose his hammer if someone else was controlling him, witch would make him unworthy?

reply

Man, Marvel really doesn't do a good job with their animated adaptions. This film was terrible and a lot of the action felt slow.

reply

[deleted]

I agree the source material itself is way better and the movie had serious flaws. Still I liked it mostly for the action.

reply

Interesting. How did Hulk "solve the mystery" with the spikes? As I did not see a mystery there.

And what was it with the blood? Namely Hulk's blood. Now it makes plants grow?

And the line about "the prophecy talks about the Sakaarson but also the worldbreaker". So there was a prophecy saying someone would either save their world or destroy it?

Yeah, this movie really relied on the viewer to have read the comic.

reply