MovieChat Forums > Oblivion (2013) Discussion > No budget for inside alien ship

No budget for inside alien ship


It was empty! What the heck?

reply

LOL!

But, seriously, what more would the AI/alien need?

On the other hand, I wish they would have spent a bit more time on the Tet, back story and such (and on the Scavs), and less on Cruise/Jack & his tech work/lake scenes ~




"Much communication in a motion, without conversation or a notion"

reply

Why would they not need things? Hated lake scenes.

reply

Well, so far as I can tell (with the paper thin background the movie gives us on the Tet), the Tet appears to be AI (no non-AI aliens on the ship I guess). Is it truly sentient? I dunno. Are there alien master controllers elsewhere (or still ones that the Tet is taking its orders from)? I dunno. Unless I missed something (the ending was so rushed).

But, if it is futuristic AI, parked & possibly following outdated orders (?) (sucking up resources, keeping the clone nursery going, etc.) or maybe still being controlled by the 'aliens' -- either way, why would it need much else? What kinds of needs do you think it would or should have? I am interested! 

Ditto regarding the 'lake' scenes. I can see a bit about it, given how the movie wraps up, but I think too much time was spent on 'lake life' (and some other Cruise scenes) that could have been spent more wisely on the Tet & the Scavs ~ not to get all overly technical or anything, but to give us more of an anchor to the story, IMHO.




"Much communication in a motion, without conversation or a notion"

reply

How does an AI repair a complicated spaceship/drone without infrastructure. Or raise a clone? Or repair itself? All very poor syfy.

reply

Weren't the clones in pod-like things, fully formed, waiting to be 'hatched' when needed?

And, yeah...I don't know about the 'repairs' issues, other than the tech clones on the planet repairing drones and the like.



"Much communication in a motion, without conversation or a notion"

reply

It really comes down to.. if you spend too much time trying to get a 'whole' backstory to a sci-fi film, you'll find something you don't like about the movie- if not a lot you don't like. A movie is supposed to be a 2 hr experience.. to take us away from our B.S lives or whatever. If you want to break apart any movie too much, it'll just lead to unhappiness.


Yeah, so this is existential movie tip- don't overthink it. Hah. As long as a movie keeps me intrigued to the end- I say mission accomplished.





---------
Hear my new song from my band, Lo. https://belo.bandcamp.com/track/unimaginable-proximity

reply

"If you want to break apart any movie too much, it'll just lead to unhappiness."

What nonsense, try watching real films

reply

Name a REAL film. I can come up with exactly one billion unanswerable questions about it. No film covers EVERYTHING. THAT's real nonsense.

reply

The Grapes of Wrath

reply

(deep breath in.....)

1. why did they live in Oklahoma instead of Texas??
2. how come Tom Joad didn't spend more time in prison?
3. what kind of tree was the preacher sitting under?
4. why was that tree there?
5. why is Muley's name spelled that way?
6. why did they use a Caterpiller tracker to knock down the house, when they could have done it by hand?
7. why did they drive a 1926 Hudson when the 1925 is vastly superior?
8. why did they drive on highway 66 when rural route 42 was much shorter?

...for the remaining 999,999,992 questions about this film, please visit: https://blog.abillionunansweredquestionsaboutthegrapesofwrath.org

reply

You obviously haven't seen the film or read the novel. Nice try, don't compare your GCI Hollywood trash nonsense "movies" to a film like the Grapes of Wrath, don't even dare do that you nincompoop

reply

No film covers EVERYTHING. NO more needs to be said. :)
Current generation weirdness of picking at everything is silly. It's JUST entertainment. Everything is not a plot hole.

Im not comparing a CGI Scifi to anything. Just pointing out EVERYTHING is not covered in EVERY FILM. Expecting it to be is just dumb.

reply

You are delusional grow the hell up idiot

reply

I know it's been years but i came here to salute you for owning the dimwit. Masterfully done, dear sir.

We never know everything in real life, yet these people believe a movie needs to show us everything that's been going on. If things in this movie happened in real life, we wouldn't have answers for any of those questions. Damn, we wouldn't even know why Tet exploded!

reply

you know you are right when they must resort to name calling. check, and mate. :)

reply

I was agreeing with you, but whatever. You're obviously kicked out anyways.

reply

oh no... im still here ;)

reply

How do you make it look deleted??

reply

oh look! SQUIRREL!!!!

reply

something that huge is VERY expensive to build-and then to have it full of empty space-just doesn't make economic sense

Same with Kubricks Space station in 2001: something like that all sterile and empty would be too expensive to build

reply

The big wheel on the Kubric sation was suppose to give artifical gravity. That is all I know and care to know about a fictional spacecraft, but point is.. not just empty space.

reply

"economic" ? Are we applying 21st century HUMAN societal ideals to something completely alien that we don't understand?
How?
Why?
Who does that??
"Being a human being, you don't know why there is so much space." is the only possible and proper answer.

reply

I liked the simplicity of the empty space. I get fed up with hugely detailed CGI which I believe they do just because they can. Most of the time the complexity confuses (me anyway) and adds nothing to the story.

reply

Maybe the empty space is necesssary for it to function properly... it's not like any of us are Alien space engineers, so let's not pretend too kuch that we know how it should work 😁... Or maybe it's not actually empty and just appears so to our human eyes... 😉

But more importantly.... having it as mostly empty imparts a strangeness to it... It is intentionally inexplicable, therefore seems even more alien to us... That is the artistic purpose behind making it that way, to generate that sense in the audience, which is the point of a movie like this 😎... Not some hypothetical space documentary about alien feats of engineering...

Movies like this must be watched with nerd glasses off... We need to resist literalist cinema-sins culture of obsessing over minutia yet missing the point of things... 😂

reply

I always assumed the vast empty spaces inside the TET was for the machines on Earth that were collecting sea water. Those things were huge and the TET was stripping the planet of its resources. I assume the TET had a destination to eventually return to so it would need a lot of room for all the crap it steals from different planets. Unless it's gone insane and is just stealing for stealing's sake, without any overall objective :D

reply

At least the Alien mothership in ID4 showed troop carriers and millions of Alien soldiers at the staging platforms ready to board their transports. The Tet ship is empty, and there is nothing practical about creating large empty artificial voids for nothing.

reply