So George Is an Old Soul and John Is a New Soul Apparently?

I would have thought they were both definitely old souls. John has way too much wisdom I'd have thought. Also, it was stated that John had a problem with women and that was one of the reasons why he was new and that it could "destroy him" I believe was the quote... well George had all kinds of affairs apparently also so I don't know if I see what that has to do with anything. So if you jerk off a lot, does that mean you aren't an old soul?