MovieChat Forums > Red White & Blue (2010) Discussion > Which character do you have the most sym...

Which character do you have the most sympathy for?


(spoilers)

I'm going to have to go with Frankie. He really seemed like a decent guy and was pushed to his breaking point. He cared for his sick mother and stopped short of infecting his ex-girlfriend who presumably cheated on him. He was also villainous in that he kept Erica tied up and eventually stabbed her, but when he killed her, he was consumed by grief for his mother who, in a way, was murdered by Erica.

I felt badly for all of the characters, though. I was also disgusted to a certain degree by all of them. I would say Nate gets the least amount of sympathy from me - he was clearly a sociopath, which began when he was a young child torturing animals.

They're coming to get you, Barbara!

reply

the stone near the front-right tire of the green pickup truck, which portrayed granite and shaped like a stoned stone would be. I liked that stone.

---------------------------
Life's too short for mediocrity.

reply

Wow. You went to a lot of trouble thinking of a relevant response to this. Thanks.

They're coming to get you, Barbara!

reply

Frankie and his mother were the only characters at all worth of any sympathy from me. Erica, (if she really knew she had hiv) deserved what she got. Nate was possibly worth of some sympathy because it's presumable that he didn't know about the HIV and thought he was avenging an innocent girl's death, but even in that case, it was clear that Nate was cold blooded and really only liked Erika because he thought she needed him, just like the kitten he had as a child that he took care of.

Conform or be cast out

reply

None.

reply

Frankie's mother.

They mostly meet me at the waterfront after the social... mostly.

reply

Erica. Hands down. Mostly because I really was torn between sympathy and complete revulsion for her, especially when it came to light how many men she had had unprotected sex with (she LOST COUNT???) But then when she revealed what had gotten her started, that's when every harsh judgment I had about her fell away. There is no condoning what she did, but you also can't count the men she slept with as completely blameless, which goes DOUBLE for Franki and his buddies. You cannot tell me by now that nobody knows the rules, even if they don't pay heed to them - you have to treat EVERY person you have sex with as someone who may be HIV-positive, even if they're not, unless they can prove to you that they're not. (And even THEN.)

But a four-year old has no choice as to whether or not sex can be forced on them, and for either not listening, not caring or not helping her daughter when she needed it most, for that I blame Erica's bitch of a mother, not her. If Erica could have gotten the help she needed when she needed it, the story of her life would have been completely different, and the deaths of a lot of innocent people could have been avoided (and that includes the ones we will never know about.)

reply

Her sleeping around with all those dudes in and of itself wasn't bad, but when she told that one guy that he shouldn't wear a condom, even though she knew she had HIV...that's pretty fu**ed up. She kind of deserved to die just for being an HIV juggernaut and then having the nerve to tell one of her former lovers "yeah HIV ain't no thang, it's really no big deal!"

Not that the other characters were any prize pigs LOL

The man who cannot visualize a horse galloping on a tomato is an idiot - Andre Breton

reply

Okay I am DYING. HIV juggernaut? 



Boredom is bullsh#t.

reply

You might as well feel sorry for every serial killer. They all had awful childhoods. Probably way worse than Erica.

reply

They all had awful childhoods

Lies.

➖➖
"I've displayed no ignorance." - Bucky after asking what the EU is

reply

Agreed Frankie (see my last post). Nate was an annoying *beep* that needed a good kicking

reply

No one mentioned the innocent little girl who got stabbed, possibly killed? I'd go with her.

reply

i felt sorry for ED and his wife and daughter. They did not deserve the treatment. Ed was a hard working fast food joint owner and his family looked so respecting. Erica was a slut and that Nate just a monster.

reply

While calling a woman a slut is *beep* gross and you're gross for it, I agree that I felt the worst for Ed and his family. Ed didn't participate in the orgy, he ran a business, and supported his family. He was put in a difficult situation when Erica died on him (in the process of trying to take her to the hospital), and may have eventually reported the crime given the time to reflect on what happened.

Erica was morally reprehensible for knowingly spreading hiv, not for sleeping around.

reply