The "why didn't they just use birth control" argument is so old and tiresome on these boards. And intellectually it is the equivalent to saying "You know, if you didn't get pregnant, you wouldn't be pregnant." Teen pregnancy is a social issue which has a much more complicated cause than "People are just stupid, guess there's no helping it."
I honestly believe a detailed, frank discussion about safe sexual intercourse should start just before puberty at school and be repeated yearly throughout. Some kids are starting to be active very young (basically when they hit puberty) and some people start when they are older, some not until college and beyond. If I start having sex at age 15, it helps me pretty much not at all if the only sex ed I am exposed to was at age 12 or will happen when I am 16.
Kids are not as dumb as their parents sometimes like to think and I in no way buy into the idea that discussing it with students "gives them ideas". They read, watch TV, listen to music, spend time with their peers, etc so believe me, they already have the ideas. Twilight the only book your tween daughter has ever voluntarily read? Yeah, sex ed will totally be what gives her ideas, not Bella spending several thousand pages of the series trying to get Edward into bed. Not knowing what exactly goes where is not stopping them and telling them in a clinical manner makes it seem less mysterious and interesting.
Also, before I say this I will mention that I was raised Catholic and am still a practicing Catholic but the amount of people on these shows that come from a religious background tells me pretty much all I ever suspected about "abstinence only" sex ed. It is a great idea to have a basis in (it was what I was taught) but you are fooling yourself if you think you don't need to provide the proper information for a plan B. Of course it would be ideal if your kid didn't have sex until marriage, but is it not preferable that in the event they don't take to that morality lesson it isn't statistically significantly more likely their relationships result in pregnancy or STIs?
reply
share