MovieChat Forums > Winnie the Pooh (2011) Discussion > Am I the only one who was left extremely...

Am I the only one who was left extremely disappointed?


I really wanted this movie to be good. I didn't believe it when my mother said she couldn't stand it and I set out to prove her wrong, that she was just being over judgemental. I'd grown up with Winnie the Pooh and will always love it.
But, my god, this movie was such a disappointment.
Maybe I just have high expectations because I remember the good Winnie the Pooh movies (Pooh's Grand Adventure: The Search for Christopher Robin, The Tigger Movie, Piglet's BIG Movie). These movies had the ability to make me laugh histerically, bust out in tears and left me with a wonderful, loving feeling by the end of it.
This version of Winnie the Pooh made me sick to my stomach throughout.
The animation was good and I was very happy Jim Cummings could still do the voices of Pooh and Tigger, but it just wasn't enough to carry the film.
All that the writers did was use old plots from previous stories of Winnie the Pooh and ruin them so that they wouldn't have to come up with anything original.
Eeyore's tail: Let's spend the entire movie slapping random objects to his butt for cheap laughs.
The red balloon: That's a recognizable object from previous episodes and movies. Let's stick that in anywhere we can with no point.
The Backson: Just ripping off Pooh's Grand Adventure where Christopher Robin goes to school and the group thinks the note reads "Skull".
The humor was dry and the characters were made out to be ten times more stupid than they actually are. The puns were awful. I saw absolutely no love or caring for one another between the characters. All I witnessed were annoyance to one another and phrases I never thought I'd hear these characters say.
Piglet is thrown around like a piece of bacon and referred to as "swine". When deciding who to throw down in the pit Roo bluntly says something like "Send the pig" in a bratty teenager's voice.
The songs were mundane and that is being generous considering the amazing songs from the previous movies. All I remember from these songs is the same phrase being repeated constantly:
"The Backson, The Backson, The Backson Backson Backson!"
"Honey, honey, honey, honey..."
"It's gonna be great, It's gonna be great..."
There was no climax. It started dull and got duller.
Where was the love? Where was the joyful, homey feeling I'm supposed to get?
I just want to understand why everyone seems to think this movie is a piece of magic. I wanted it to be good, but I'm just left feeling sick.

reply

You summed up basically how I felt about this movie. Everyone said this was good, but it just didn't click with me.

reply

I felt the exact opposite. For someone who's never like Winnie the Pooh I actually thought the movie was hilarious. Earlier this year I started with Snow White and proceeded to watch all 51 Disney animated films in order just finishing tonight. I found the The Many Adventures of Winnie Pooh to be incredibly boring so I wasn't look forward to this one. To my surprise this one managed to keep me entertained the whole way through.
---
Committed Brony

reply

Nice to see someone who shares my opinion, brian577.

I'm only missing a couple of Disney's 52 animated films, but I think The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh is the single worst one so far, even worse than AristoCats and Oliver & Company.

I was really not looking forward to yet another Winnie the Pooh movie. But I did kind of enjoy this one. It's easy for me to figure out why though. Eeyore was my favorite character in the original movie, and he was barely in it. So seeing a lot more Eeyore was a major improvement. Plus, I liked that this movie had an actual plot. Now, I know that a plot isn't really necessary for movies; in fact a lot of my favorites don't have any plot. But since I hate most of the Pooh characters, having a plot, and more Eeyore, made this movie fine.

---
I know what gold does to men's souls.

reply

I really loved this movie as someone who has loved Winnie the Pooh all my life.

Metallica, Iron Maiden, and My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic fan

reply

Glad to see I'm not the only one who wasn't able to enjoy this movie.
The first time I watched it I couldn't help but hate the whole thing.
After re-watching it I have to say it's not really a BAD movie, but I'm still wondering why people like it so much compared to the others.

reply

Voice acting was good, but I found Owl's mis-reading of the note into "Backson" to be incredibly stupid; it pretty much wrecked the rest of the show, mostly since the Backson song was so annoying.

reply

Yes; that was what I really didn't like about it. I hated the Backson scene; how it builds up, how it comes about, and the song. Another thing; the songs are not as good as everyone says they are either.

reply

That's nothing new, in Pooh's Grand Adventure: The Search for Christopher Robin he misreads "School" as "Skull".

Favourite movie of all time: "Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan"

reply

It was HOR-RI-BAD. A couple of the songs were catchy, that'sa about the only good thing I can say about the movie.

The tigger voice is awful. Jim Cummings seems like a great guy (I heard he calls sick kids in the hospital in his spare time) but he really should have let someone else do the voice of tigger.

In the original movie the characters are charmingly naiive. In this movie they are flat out dumb and owl borders on maliciously dumb.

reply

nah, we're just getting older ;)

winnie the pooh is amazing.

reply

nah, we're just getting older ;)

winnie the pooh is amazing.


👍😜

MYRTLE SNOW WILL NOT BE SILENCED!!

reply

Is that person talking about Winnie the Pooh himself/the franchise, or the 2011 film? In my opinion, that movie was NOT amazing, and I'm a die hard Pooh fan who first received a plush of him at age one (and I still have him!).

reply

I wasn't really disappointed with the quality of it, Instead I was disappointed with the length of it. It only lasted about as long as a normal t.v episode. I'd still take the classic 1977 version of it though.

reply

I completely agree with you, Kieska317. It was nothing compared to the original 1977 movie, which I thought was great.

reply

No you were not. I HATED this film. Also, my poor poor Kanga (she's one of my fave characters) was extremely out of character...

It was good, but when the Backson song came on, that's when the ball of crap was dropped.

Most of the "comedy" in there was extremely unfunny, Pooh and Piglet's  faces were pretty much mine watching Rabbit's weird stuff (and call me weird, but I thought Rabbit's POed faces were scary, they actually scared me).

And yeah, it's completely a rip-off of Pooh's Grand Adventure, which was an AWESOME film. That didn't even scare me as a kid. I thought this film would be like the Many Adventures film (one of my favorite movies of all time! ) when I saw the description saying the stories it would adapt would be the Piglet Heffalump one, the one with Eeyore losing his tail, and the one with Rabbit having a busy day and finding out what Christopher Robin would do in the mornings.

Eeyore, Pooh, CR, and Piglet were probably the best characters who were in character here.

Do you know what my favorite part of the film was? The credits where we saw the plushies interacting the scenes from the film (I thought it was cute, along with the opening). That's not a good sign...

What a big letdown this film was...

reply

Yes. I wasn't really a big fan of this movie either. I loved the Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh growing up, but this movie was kind of weak.
This movie looked and felt like a Winnie the Pooh movie, but the whole thing felt off. The stories were weak in my opinion, especially dedicating the majority of the movie towards the "Backson" plotline. It didn't really hold a candle to Pooh getting stuck in Rabbit's house or the Hefflelump sequence of the original. Also, they made Owl very dimwitted. I know Pooh is meant to be a little dimwitted but he seemed more dimwitted in this film than usual.

I also didn't think Craig Ferguson's voice really worked as Owl and every time Rabbit spoke, all I heard was Spongebob.

It did have some funny moments and I liked the return of 2D animation and style of the original, but it just didn't work for me.

Don't you hate it when horror movie posters are scarier than the movie itself?

reply

I thought the movie was good, fun, and charming. I'm surprised to see how many people think the movie was horrible.

reply

[deleted]

It only seems like a minority or maybe, 25% thinks it's bad. The majority of people I've seen on here who's seen it love it, for reasons I cannot understand why.

reply

I agree entirely. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh was one of my first movies!

The best part for this IMO (besides some parts like the sneezing joke and the plush interacting on the credits) was probably the fact they used 2D for this.

And yeah, I heard Spongebob with Rabbit too. I also didn't care for Kanga's voice.

Yeah, it's sad when previews and posters look so much more promising and promise more excitement than the actual product.

reply