MovieChat Forums > Hearat Shulayim (2011) Discussion > Please explain-[SPOILERS]

Please explain-[SPOILERS]


In the films opening we see the son accepting the prestigious Israel prize and the father angry and rejected after so many years of hard work and being nominated but still never receiving the prize that his son has now won.The film even shows him not having the symbolic bracelet that means he is part of the community. But at the end we see the Father getting the prize and the bracelet although due to a big mix up that is dealt with and explained during the middle of the film.So what is the viewer to believe? Did the father or the son actually win the prize?Is one of these sequences a fantasy sequence? If it is the filmmaker gives no clues visual or otherwise that it is. Did I miss something? Otherwise I really enjoyed this film but this aspect left me confused and in the end took away the otherwise greatness of this film. Anyone that can enlighten me would be much appreciated.

reply

You misunderstood the opening sequence. The ceremony there was Uriel's induction into the Israel Academy of Sciences and Humanities (not the awarding of the Israel Prize). The blue plastic bracelet was not any indicator of status, but just a method of maintaining security (Eliezer hadn't received one, presumably because of some oversight).

reply

Mathew saved me the trouble.

I want to shake every limb in the Garden of Eden
and make every lover the love of my life

reply

I believe Eliezer takes the bracelet off while listening to his son's speech and tosses it away, not giving it another thought.

reply

Two nice, attractive ladies in the theater where I watched the film made the same mistake as the OP here. They asked me about it on the way out of the auditorium and accepted my correction. I think it is the evil influence of all those movies that are twisted out of chronological order, a la Q. Tarantino.

reply


Yes, two different awards. There was that one fantasy sequence though where Eliezer imagines himself back at his son's induction and stands up and shouts that he is a philologist and not a "teacher." He's wearing the lavender shirt the TV show producer gave him to wear.

reply

In the films opening we see the son accepting the prestigious Israel prize...


On the first viewing, I had the same misunderstanding that the first ceremony was for the Israel Prize (rather than the Israel Academy of Sciences and Humanities). I even tried to concoct some complex scheme of flashbacks that would make it work.

On second viewing it was quite clear though that ceremony was something different, and the film was in strict chronological order. What I got then was that a) the son likes getting lots of awards, and b) the father thinks his son is too award-concious.


...The blue plastic bracelet was not any indicator of status, but just a method of maintaining security (Eliezer hadn't received one, presumably because of some oversight).


It's a common part of autism to be hyper-sensitive to clothing that feels rough and to unfamiliar clothing. You've probably heard stories of mothers ripping all the tags out of all the clothing of their autistic offspring. So once the suggestion Eliezer's peronality was partly due to autism was available, the idea of him absent-mindedly being annoyed by his wrist strap and ripping it off seemed quite normal.

Maybe Eliezer didn't even clearly remember exactly what he had done. When he got home he tried to "fix" his watchband ...but it didn't appear to be broken. It's possible all he remembered was some sense that _something_ that went around his wrist hadn't been quite right.

(There were other suggestions of autistic behavior in that first setting: him standing up after everyone else and sitting down before everyone else, his purposeful straight walk from the outside door clear to the bench on the other side of the patio, his being completely alone all the time, his complete focus on a stranger's conversation that was almost out of earshot, his at-first-puzzled then-quite-indignant response to being questioned by the security guard, and his bewilderment at his son's schmoozing.)

reply

Chuckman, I have read your multiple posts on this board pressing the autism angle... and I can't believe you conclude what you do about Ezriel being autistic

Uriel's wife screamed it at him as an insult. She just as well could have screamed "Tell your OCD dad.." or "Tell your insane dad..." And if either of those two words were used, they would not imply some "key" to Ezriels behavior... he is not OCD or insane. And he is not Autistic, rather the woman was just angry at her husband for taking out his frustration on Yosh.

reply

Agree, the word "autistic" was by no means a medical diagnosis. I would even think that the use of the word was offensive, the wife used it flippantly in much the same way the word "retard" is used to insult someone's intelligence.

reply

Thank you very much. I was so confused about that point that after watching the movie I went back to see if there had been some point of divergence I had missed, finally concluding that it must have had a science fiction parallel universe element in it. They really should have done a better job to make the point that the opening segment was NOT the awarding of the prize, because it rendered so much of the movie confusing for me (and obviously others).

reply