MovieChat Forums > Mientras duermes (2011) Discussion > 2 Stupid decisions and 1 question

2 Stupid decisions and 1 question


First stupid decision i couldn't explain:

Why in heck would Cesar hide his rape-kit not only in her flat but also in the mattress itself? That's making sure that she will know sooner or later, increasing the chances of ever getting caught. Why not bring everything with you? Would you bet your freedom on the off chance she won't lift her mattress one day when she's cleaning or redecorating? I know i wouldn't.

Second stupid decision:

Why the heck would the boyfriend confront an obviously disturbed person in such an amateurish way? Did he have a death wish? I mean, obviously and without hesitation, the first step is to call the cops, but if you want to play the tough guy, her being your GF and all, fine, but then take some freakin precautions! Would you really bet your life on the slight possibility that the guy is not completely crazy and that he is weaker than you, that you can overpower him whenever you will feel like it? I know i wouldn't. What was he doing to Cesar on the bed anyway? Trying to crush his head against a pillow? That's just useless in any version of reality, anywhere, anytime.

Question:

I notice we never got to know what Cesar had in store for Clara that day she came home with the BF. I can only imagine what twisted stuff he had in mind that night. What do you think his plan was, rape and kill? Probably.
Now that i think of it, it seems he had something planed that was out-of-character compared to the rest we have seen him doing and i find it hard to believe that after he made the decision to finally cross the line of barbarism (whatever he had planed), he would go back to his usual stalking. In my humble opinion, he is a serial-killer that doesn't know it. They often start this way, with smaller crimes and infractions (arson, larceny, petty crimes and/or sexual assaults, animal cruelty etc.) until fantasizing doesn't cut it anymore and they have to up the ante one way or another, which often means killing. Decreasing in intensity doesn't sound credible. Thoughts?

Anyway, all that being said, don't let this apparent rant fool you, i really enjoyed the movie and was on the edge of my seat about 10min in. Such an unusual story, slightly reminiscing of other works such as With a Friend like Harry... or The Lives of Others. Luis Tosar, the actor playing Cesar, is the perfect fit for the role, very convincing, almost charismatic and Clara is a pure delight.

7/10.


People who don't like their beliefs being laughed at shouldn't have such funny beliefs

reply

Regarding the second item, you are projecting your own behaviors and thought processes onto the boyfriend character. That's unfair for at least a few reasons. One, you aren't him. There are plenty of stupid, hot-headed people in this world who think they can handle everything themselves. Plenty. Two, you presumably haven't been in that situation, at that point in your life, feeling those feelings, with that personality, so you don't really know how you might behave.

reply

Regarding your first item, I'd say just keep in mind that the main character isn't a caricature. He's a flawed human being who makes mistakes, just like the rest of us. Maybe there was something thrilling in being so close to the line of getting caught for him. Who knows. A depression that severe (like what he describes) could lead to all sorts of bizarre behavior (like trying to inflict the ultimate soul-crush on someone in order to not feel alone).

reply

1. When was the last time you looked that far under your mattress? Back in the day, when we used to flip mattresses it would’ve been a thing but now with pillow tops, etc. people don’t flip mattresses anymore. Personally I had a bigger problem with her dancing around the room and not even catching a glimpse of something under the bed.

2. Thought the same thing. He already semi-confronted the guy. Call the friggin’ cops.

3. Considering his creepiness throughout the movie, I don’t want to imagine.

reply