MovieChat Forums > Held Hostage (2009) Discussion > main character and plot annoyed me[ spoi...

main character and plot annoyed me[ spoilers]


Her constant naivity and stupidity when questioned by the police and in court bothered me. Yes, she had a bad background, but now she had a responsible position in a bank, so she couldn't have been that tongue-tied, stupid and uncooperative with the police. Also, why didn't she write more details on a note when she had the chance in the bank, such as where to find her daughter--so police could have gone to the house right away? Also, the thugs would have known that even though she thought she had a microphone, they couldn't see her, so she could write notes or pantomime or stand near something noisy to whisper, etc,etc. What good would detonating the bombs [if they were real] have done the crooks?--they wouldn't get their money and would be in much worse trouble.
Let's say, she had reneged and they then told her they had killed the girl, why would she have gone ahead and robbed the bank for them after that?

reply

The film was directly based on a true story.

I would imagine, that most people in such a situation would be too scared to think as clearly as you suspect during such a crisis.

reply

not to mention the awful ending...
prosecution has the mind set of a teenage boy for one, "exotic dancer, haha, isnt that prostitution?" yeah ok if you're 13 you might think like that.

And finally. She looks totally guilty and the bad guy looks innocent until her speech about how she loves her daughter. How ridiculous.
"Oh you love your daughter?, ok we're sorry, he's guilty not you."

Lifetime for ya

reply