MovieChat Forums > Jin ling shi san chai (2011) Discussion > For a better film about "the rape of nan...

For a better film about "the rape of nanking"...


Watch "John Rabe." It's a movie based on real events, without the shmaltzy tone of this one and without the buffoonish carrying on of Christian Bale.

See the Rotten Tomatoes page on it John Rabe here: http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/john_rabe/

reply

Both were excellent films.

reply

Stop talking nonsense man! Both these films were great! It doesn't matter if this movie here, is not based on true persons or not. It's the settings ... the direction...the performances and so on, that it matters! Learn how to watch a good movie, and stop playing jerk!

reply

I rewatched this recently, a few years after my original post above, and I have to say now that I enjoyed it. It got better as the story developed, which makes me think I didn't watch the whole movie the first time around. Ah me.

reply

I gave this a watch years ago and thought it was pretty good. Gave it a rewatch and it’s so heartbreaking. I wish they would’ve told us what happened to the brothel women.

reply

They died. Duh! It's 80 years ago dude!

reply

Well of course they are all dead *now*. But I mean in the immediate aftermath of the movie events. Were they really taken to a party? Did they really sing? Did they get to escape? The ending was too ambiguous for my taste, although it was a great film regardless.

reply

It is a work of fiction; nothing happens after the last scene.

reply