Stifler's in order from best to worst.


1. Steve
2. Matt (Band camp)
3. Dwight (Naked Mile and Beta House)
4. Eric (Naked Mile and Beta House)
5. The one from book of love, forget his name.


Overall the first 4 movies were the best, hands down, the newer ones are basically softcore pornos lol

reply

1. Steve (American Pie 1, 2 & Wedding)
2. Dwight (Naked Mile & Beta House)
3. Matt (American Pie 1, 2 & Band Camp)
4. Scott (Book Of Love)
5. Eric (Naked Mile & Beta House)

reply

[deleted]

Steve
Dwight
Scott
Matt
Eric

reply

Steve
Matt
Dwight
Eric
Scott (omg he was so damn ANNOYING!!)

say my name

reply

Steve
Eric
Dwight
Matt
Scott (how in the world could they not cast a better stifler)

reply

[deleted]

steve
dwight
matt
eric
scott

reply

Steve
Matt Stifler (AP1 & 2)
Dwight
Matt Stifler from Band Camp
Eric
Random Robot talking loser from Book of Love

reply

1. Steve
2. Dwight (Naked Mile and Beta House)
3. Matt (Band camp)
4. Eric (Naked Mile and Beta House)
5. The one from book of love, forget his name also haha

reply

eric
steve
dwight
matt
scott

reply

steve
matt
dwight
eric
scott (wtf was that?!)
Only Spartak(Varna)!

reply

i didnt even read the rest of this thread but im just going to throw it out there that matt stiffler was the worst

he took steves attitude and motions and talk that sean william scott put in the charater and just totally was over the top to the point that the character wasnt even beleivable

reply

[deleted]

i absolutely agree with your list. Steve was just legendary, and Matt was actually pretty sweet (and hot, dont forget freaking hot).

The one from the book of love just sucks.

I Amsterdam

reply

Are we talking from a viewer's perspective, or in terms of which would you rather be friends with if they existed? Unlike the rest of his kin, Dwight seemed to be more of a leader and he actually had the respect of his peers. Steve, on the other hand, had no real friends, and noone took him seriously.

reply

Dwight was the most popular of all the Stifler's at least in the movies etc.

1.steve
2.dwight
3.matt
4.eric
5.scott

reply

Eric and Dwight are the only ones who aren't *beep*
Steve is, but he's so fun. Matt is meh, and Scott sucks.

So..

1: Eric
2: Dwirght
3: Steve
4: Matt
5: Scott

reply

I haven't yet seen this order

Steve (absolutely legendary)
Dwight (very lovable)
Eric (also very lovable)

matt
scott

i couldnt put matt and scott with the others. they were totally and undenyably horrible.

What we have with my top three, are characters with their own personalities.

Matt, seriously, i was watching it ashamed that i bought this dvd. matt tryed too *beep* hard to be like Steve, i mean come on, show some original characterization huh.

Scott was very similar to both matt and steve. get your own *beep* characterization and people wouldnn't despise your characters so much.

reply

Steve
Dwight
Eric
Matt
Scott

You're like a giant... cock blocking robot, like developed in a secret *beep* government lab.

reply

Steve/Dwight
Eric
Matt
Scott (WHAT THE FVCK!)

Steve was funnier but Dwight was loved by everyone, pretty cool and more laid back.
Eric was a really good take on the Stifler family. He wasn't an @sshole, but he wasn't some annoying loser either.
Matt was trying too hard to be Sean William Scott and Scott was the worst Stifler possible. He looked way too old, didn't have any likable qualities and was not funny in the slightest.

My Movie Ratings:
http://www.imdb.com/mymovies/list?l=32978565

reply

Scott looked way too old.

reply

1) Dwight
2) steve
3) erik
4) matt
5) book of love dude.

reply

1. Eric (Naked Mile and Beta House)
2. Dwight (Naked Mile and Beta House)
3. Steve (American Pie 1 and 2, American Wedding, and American Reunion)
4. Matt (Band Camp)

The reason why I haven't put Scott on the list is because I have yet to see the Book of Love. Here are my reasons for the listing: Eric is a nice guy and really, really cares for people and is not an *beep* Dwight, because he's still the wild side of Steve, but he's not as much of a dick as him. Steven because he ate dog crap to save a ring, he wanted people to see blue dicks, and he wanted to give everybody a cool after-prom party people will never forget. Matt because he was annoying, his best parts were when he decided to make things right with the band geeks, and when he came out blaring the bagpipes. Oh, and the nut shot with the staff to that snooty rich kid priss.

Well, that's my list! See ya!

"I wish I could quit you!" So do I, you fricking idiotic cowboys!

reply

1. Steve (Original and the King)
2. Dwight (Best Stifler, leading and rocking)
3. Matt (Nice, pretended to be "Stifler")
4. Eric
5. Scott (Well... still Stifler)

reply