MovieChat Forums > Mine vaganti (2010) Discussion > Why does the grandmother eat so much 'ca...

Why does the grandmother eat so much 'cake'?


I don't understand why the grandmother eat so much cake toward the end. Could someone enlighten me please?

reply

She had diabetes. She chooses to die eating.

reply

Thank you for replying. I am sorry I tried to veil my original question, intending it to mean why did she choose to commit suicide? As Roman Catholic is the "official" religion of Italy, the grandmother character must have known it is a mortal offense religiously to commit suicide.

Anyone else who can offer an insight?

Thank you.

reply

In a very wide sense, your question about Catholic religion, Italians' religion and Italians' attitude towards suicide is a very tough question, which I think I am not able to answer to.

With respect to the grandmother character:
as you could realize, she is probably the most open-minded person of the whole family, the only one able to understand and to be part of the secrets of her nephews, she has had a very particular life, a marriage with a man and an unconfessed (because unrealizable) life-long love with the husband brother, probably she has a vision of life for which death is only a necessary step ahead.
Her voice is left behind to those who will always love her, as she states in the very last quotes of the movie.
Very touching ....

reply

Calling it suicide seems a little extreme. Yes, she knowingly ate the cake. But the diabetes(ilnness) took her life. She died naturally.

reply

of course it's suicide.

it's like driving fast in traffic and going to a opposite direction track on purpose, and then after being killed not calling it a suicide, but accident.

All Is One

reply

Being quite the insightful, smart character I doubt she was stupid enough to believe that fairy tales would cause her eternal damnation.

reply


Suicide By cake, that's a new one.


When there's no more room in hell, The dead will walk the earth...

reply

Well, there are worse ways to end one's life...

reply

Most of her life she was denied something - first, love with her brother-in-law, later in her life she had to restraint herself in eating because of her diabetes. One day she has had enough and decided to let loose and get what she actually wanted. For once, she was free.

reply