I will be the lone dissenter here. I like JGL tremendously (though lately he's been going the Johnny Depp corporate blockbusters/big paydays route too often). Mysterious Skin...his best performance imo. But this film, I can see why it appealed to him...the chance to stretch and try a new road. But his performance is too strenuous, "actorish" and a tad obvious for me. I can see the strings so to speak. I can see Oz behind the curtain. He tries too hard in many scenes. More subtlety can be achieved (even for a loud explosive personality as Hesher). Portman was even worse imo. Her clothes made her look like a Mama's Family castmate. I totally didn't buy her trying to submerge herself into her role. The silly wardrobe drag made it even more unintentionally comical for me. Rainn Wilson was good as was the boy and the pro's pro Piper Laurie. Sorry to say that on many levels Hesher didn't light my candle.
reply
share