MovieChat Forums > Winter's Bone (2010) Discussion > After watching it for the second time

After watching it for the second time


It's really much more better than when I saw it for the first time. Quite crazy, I got it back then that it was a good movie but when I saw it for the first time it was quite boring to me. Not anymore.

But Jennifer was excellent and it's definitely a better role for her than Silver Linings Playbook or American Hustle's roles. And some of her young fans from the Hunger Games may give it a chance once they are older.

I have no words...so just enjoy over 2000 videos http://www.youtube.com/user/yinloveyang

reply

[deleted]

I've probably seen it about 10 times...and that is no word of a lie. Love this film!

reply

The first time I saw it was the week it opened. I don't think I was in my seat a full 60 seconds, when I thought to myself, " I think I'm in for something special ". Boy, was I ever right! One of the very best of the decade.

reply

Pivot has had it on several times but I keep missing the beginning so i got it off ebay. Excellent movie IMO. The acting was great and for those complaining that there is no plot they need to stop watching their pitiful fantasy movies. Yes, there is a plot. Girl is looking for her druggie dad in order to save her house. What's so complicated about that.

reply

Welcome to IMDb. I still enjoy it as much as I did when I joined almost 14 years ago.

By the way, Winter's Bone is playing at 6PM and 8:30PM ( Pacific Time ) on Saturday, in case you want to recommend it to anyone.

reply

Thanks for the welcome but I've been on IMDB for a while. I just forgot the password I used for the other account so I logged in with my FB account:)

Thanks for the heads up too! I'll probably watch it tonight. We're getting a snowstorm here in Colorado so what better to do that stay in and watch a good movie!

reply

It's 65 degrees right now, just north of SF. Eat your heart out. I'm presently watching ' The Film Independent Spirit Awards ' on IFC. I haven't watched The Oscars in about twenty years, but I try not to ever miss this. Winter's Bone was nominated for seven and won two awards on the 2010 show. I had never heard of ' Pivot ' until you mentioned it. Not a bad programming lineup. Thanks. Steve

P.S. What is the significance of the numbers in your user name, if I'm not being too nosy?

reply

I think it's a great movie. It is real, not some hollywood happy ending kind of film where everything turns out rosy in the end. This is a bleak movie, but it portrays how things really are in severe poverty and when you are dealing with a bunch of rednecks who are all in the same sleazy business. Blood is definitely not thicker than water among that bunch; they are all out to just save their own skin, even when that witch comes to Ree after beating her half to death to "help you solve your problem." She only did it because too many people were talking about her and that husband of hers and it was making them nervous.

reply

Ree broke the rules and suffered the consequences for it. I am glad the movie stuck to the gritty representation of it. I kinda wish they had shown the actual beating tho, but the way they portrayed it was effective.

You can call the woman that took her to her dad a witch if you want, but the fact is that it was an act of kindness.

The truth is she did for Ree what nobody else would do, and quite frankly she did it at great peril to herself. If Ree decided to go to the cops and reveal how she found her father, it would have blown back on the "witch" big time, like in a life ending way.

Ree asked her mom what she should do, but it was the "witch" who seemed to help her the most. Also, it is worth considering that it was that very beating that actually kept her from getting killed by Thurmont (i.e., she had been punished, she's learned her lesson, no need to kill her). So believe it or not, in some ways she was a substitute mom.

Seriously, helping Ree would not end any gossip, more than likely it would just feed more gossip...it was her conscious eating at her that motivated her.

reply

Ironically the film did leave out the most hopeful part of the book -- the bondsman says he may offer her a job when she's older, because she won out over nearly impossible odds.

reply

This post has been deleted.

This post has been deleted. Again.

reply