'They know that trick.'


Ah yes, the old chop your hand off to get out of going to prison trick. That one's easily the oldest in the book. Who in the world came up with that line?

reply

It may be surprising but it is not the first time I've heard it said and possibly done. It's a more extreme form of literally shooting yourself in the foot to get out of combat in times of war.

reply

I guess if your IQ is around room temperature, you're poor as dirt, you're wanted on several murder charges, and you've been smoking meth for two weeks... maybe... just maybe I could see someone thinking of this brilliant idea. But, has anyone ever actually gone through with it? Like, can you find me a real world example of someone actually doing this?

reply

I've only heard it as anecdotal, never anyone confirmed to do it. Though I could find real life examples of people wounding themselves to get out of being deployed, I've never seen anyone who actually did cut off a hand to fake their death but I have no doubt there are people dumb and desperate enough to try it.

reply

Cause forensics experts can't differentiate between a hand severed from a cadaver vs. a live body? I mean, really.

reply

No one who cuts off their own hand to escape prison can be accused of having intelligence to begin with.

reply

I would like to know why they cut his hands off instead of giving her back the body?

reply


I guessed it was because the body in general might show clues that would give away the murderer. Besides, the cover story -- "somebody threw this sack onto my porch" -- would be a lot less plausible if the whole body was involved.

reply

True and I got the impression the body was heavy enough to sink the boat since it was frozen.

reply

Why take the woman to the body? Cut off the hands and fling them on her porch, less trouble and she won't know *beep*

my vote history:
http://www.imdb.com/user/ur13767631/ratings

reply

Why take the woman to the body?
The idea was I think that in raising the corpse enough from the bottom of the pond to a point where they could remove the hands, Ree could see it was her father and stop searching.

If they'd just thrown the hands on to the porch, as per her cover story, she might never have been convinced they were her father's hands.

reply

Police had his fingerprints on file. That would convince her alright.



my vote history:
http://www.imdb.com/user/ur13767631/ratings

reply

The idea was I think that in raising the corpse enough from the bottom of the pond to a point where they could remove the hands, Ree could see it was her father and stop searching.
I think they felt this form of closure would be more appropriate.

reply

That's correct, the genre is macabre realism so fishing for the body was a necessary element of the story. It's also a form of violence.

my vote history:
http://www.imdb.com/user/ur13767631/ratings

reply

I wish it was just a gross detail made up. It's not. I'm sorry to say. Google it. Yuck.

reply

Yeah, because that's what I get every time I've ever helped chainsaw off my parents' hands. Closure.




I want the doctor to take your picture so I can look at you from inside as well.

reply

Police had his fingerprints on file. That would convince her alright.

===========================

Yeah, I'm sure that she'd take the hands to the police and say "Somebody threw these on the porch. Could you check and see if they are my Dad's?" Because if they aren't, she could be charged with involvement in some new murder. This is a family where nobody deals with the police if they can avoid it. Ree had to be sure that they were her Dad's hands before going out on a limb.

reply

Ree was hopeless, so she'd have taken severed hands to police anyway. I doubt they'd try to go after her unless they had some other incriminating evidence.

my vote history:
http://www.imdb.com/user/ur13767631/ratings

reply

Why take the woman to the body? Cut off the hands and fling them on her porch, less trouble and she won't know *beep*

Exactly. Sooooo stupid. They did it because the entire movie was a boring mess, and it had to have at least one scene to remember the movie by.





I want the doctor to take your picture so I can look at you from inside as well.

reply

Not to say it is smart, clearly it is not, but the idea is to make law enforcement believe you are dead, so that they quit searching. Sure, if he gets caught, a ID search in NCIC will show future LEOs that he is supposed to be dead and may even offer more information, like him being wanted for other charges prior to his death. However, it is easier to avoid capture if no one is looking, because they believe him dead. It is even more likely that if he flees to another state that the local county or US Justice Department isn't going to update wanted files on a local drug dealer that was arrested for cooking meth...In reality, he wouldn't wouldn't even need to fake his death to avoid capture. For those charges, just leaving the state would probably be enough. Faking his death would be more of an attempt to not have his bond revoked. Sometimes, if a felony warrant from a county or two away pops up, they won't bother with extradition. I have ran someone that had robbery warrants, a violent crime, out of Ohio and requested extradition, and was denied a hold because they refused to send a YQ(dispatcher talk, I don't know what it means) and were not going to come to get the suspect...So, if he had convinced the courts or bond service that he was dead, by giving up a body part, and his bond was not revoked and the property or money was released, it would have worked and he would have been a free man. Maybe just free in the undocumented criminal world, but that is usually the circles that drug dealers travel in. It is an organized crime thing, probably not done so much in the hill billy meth cooking world, but they had them way to structured for the movie as it was, buy it's a movie, so whatever.

reply

Mr Handdropoff came out with that line!

Its that man again!!

reply

[deleted]

NotAnUndercoverCopĀ» Ah yes, the old chop your hand off to get out of going to prison trick. That one's easily the oldest in the book. Who in the world came up with that line?


Clyde Barrow had two of his toes chopped off so he could get out of work duty while in Prison. Stranger things have happened. Sometimes you just can't make this stuff up.

ī€Life is like Wikipedia: There are no Facts, Just Popular Opinion

reply

Not really unbelievable. If you knew going to prison meant certain death - like if a rival gang was out to kill you once you were inside - cutting off a hand might be a reasonable option.

reply