MovieChat Forums > La doppia ora (2009) Discussion > Sorry he should have turned her in...Spo...

Sorry he should have turned her in...Spoilers


Even though I understood the romantic plot and why he could not do it, It's still up to a good person to turn her in. Lets face it she dumped him after using him, so in the end by karma she is not a good person. I am fascinated when there is love one is supposed to be doing the right thing, if this was the case every cop falling for a widow who murdered her husband would go free. For those who say he learned to love, so he will be even more hesitant when the next woman who means him well, he will not trust her. Just how is he better off letting her go. He is bound to do the right thing no matter how he feels and it's not like she would have done the same for him if this was reversed.

reply

The point of this film is the power of love, not how to "do the right thing".


---
"Don't just DO something, STAND there!"
Pastor Charlie Bing

reply

Why is most posters talking about love so much with this film, I just did not see all the romance the way it played out. He may have convinced himself she was the one but i never got that from her. She knew what was going on from the beginning and fell for him in a endearing/sexual manner but not love. I agree the film is a love story from his POV BUT IT HAS SEVERAL POINTS. Including trust values, and one should believe in there ways of doing what is right.

reply

Well, the film shows that Guido was no dream date either. He is a womanizer and not very nice. Yes, he lost his wife. But that did not give him a free pass to abuse every woman who came into his life through that speed dating service.

Guido met his match with Sonia. Despite being tied to that boyfriend, I think there were many dupes just like Guido. But Guido was the one victim who touched whatever was left of her soul.

So they both got their just desserts. In a way. She is rich and lives with a man she does not love. The one she does love, she will never see again. In turn the womanizer got played by a man eater. He experienced how one of his dates felt after he kicked them out of his apartment.

reply

You Say...... In a way. She is rich and lives with a man she does not love. The one she does love, she will never see again. In turn the womanizer got played by a man eater. He experienced how one of his dates felt after he kicked them out of his apartment.

When did the film express how she felt about her current boyfriend, If a guy can get a woman to do what she did, I would think she was in love with him. The plan was if sex was necessary, she would do it this means she would have done this with anyone to achieve there goal. I felt in the end she did not like what she had to do with a man like him, he in her eyes was blinded, and her great sex, and persona worked to make him that way as she knew he would let them go, turns out she was right in the end. She felt guilty about what she had done not sad for getting rich and them achieving there goals at his demise. They both are better without each other as he will love someone and stop using woman, and she gets her new life style.

I am not tying to change how you saw the film but giving you more to chew on.

reply

The boyfriend knew something was up when he found the two of them kissing. That led him to making that big show that ended up with Sonia getting shot.

If this was a regular ploy, with Sonia being the siren, than being bothered by Sonia's act shouldn't have occurred to him. But it did. So he had suspicions.

And the love scene before she runs away was Sonia acting on the feelings that were building. She found out it was real but could not stay because of the heist.

reply

Where do I start.....It was needed for him to feel as he did, It may not have started out that way but they were shifting on the move. I am not saying she did not have feelings for him, as she did, but she felt sorry for him being the one she absolutely had to get in her corner by any means needed. She is SURE he will not turn them in because she knew how he felt. You are vastly under rating what had to be done and are seeing the love making as a admittance of true love when it really was an act of getting his love for the plan to work. MAYBE A ROMP IN THE SACK FOR GOOD MEASURE, OBVIOUSLY IT WAS BETTER THAN EXPECTED.


Film makers are very good in getting romantics to see that side and are equally good at getting others to see it another way. Some of the times it has nothing to do with true love yet romantics feel it did. As the female leads job is for just that, but there are several other things floating that are more important to what the filmmaker is truly saying.

In this case here we have a woman whom will do anything with her partner to achieve there goals yet she is in sadness that this guy was a good man whom she cared for. Sort of feeling remorse as how it played out. Yes she cared for him but sleeping with a guy, liking sex with him does not have to be a whirlwind romance to some women.

There is no reason for the director to show how she feels or interacts with her boyfriend because it is spelling it out in what she is doing with him, She is a woman who if not for him would have loved to be with the ex-cop. It's all in the reflection at the end, he was a good one who she will remember. No more no less. They both moved on.

reply

I agree.

I just don't think the movie built a sufficiently persuasive platform to convince us that Guido (an ex-cop) was that much in love with Sonia, as to essentially give everything away to a known criminal who has cheated him.

Inversely, I find it hard to fathom as to why Sonia would return so readily to the guy who was almost responsible for her death.

Ain't love grand!🐭

reply

So why do you figure he gave her the necklace?


Surreal Cinema: http://www.imdb.com/list/ls006574276/

reply

Sorry Dingo, I haven't seen the film for 15 months, so I wouldn't like to speculate on that one.🐭

reply

After the scene were Sonia is seen leaving with her boyfriend for Buenos Aires, Guido is seen with a bunch of guys in a bar drinking. One of the men looked like his police friend who tried to warn him earlier. This scene suggested that he probably told on her and hence is hanging out with the cop friends.

Also in the last scene were Sonia takes in a pic with her boyfriend, she is fiddling caressing the locket Guido gifted her. This again suggests that she is still in love with him.

The scene were we see Guido speed dating refers to his accepting his past and moving on.

reply