MovieChat Forums > Black Mass (2015) Discussion > Depp is awful as usual. Should have been...

Depp is awful as usual. Should have been Liotta


Depp is a bad, bad actor. He was awful in this. Looks more like Ray Liotta that Bulger and Liotta should have played the part anyway. The rest of the cast was fantastic. Could have been an 8/10 but Depp drops it 5/10.

reply

Completely disagree

reply

The OP is dead wrong..Depp was great.

reply

1000% wrong. Depp gave an incredible performance, and the overall film was very well done.

reply

Agree.

reply

Depp nail Jimmie Bulger. Ray Liotta can play a great gansta, but he is no Whitey.

reply

You're either very very wrong or just a troll.

reply

Liotta would have been a really good choice! And, at his age, he wouldn't have required all the makeup that Depp was buried under.

Supposedly, Bulger really liked the way Depp looked. I thought Depp's performance was quite good, but was very distracted by the amount of makeup. It just made him look very bizarre and freakish to me. Bulger in real life was much more normal looking. I think Liotta could've pulled it all off rather nicely.

reply

I was locked up in prison with Jimmie... He would invite me to his cell to show me pictures that fans sent him of Johnny Depp playing him in the movie. You should see the smile on that 86 now 87 year old mans Face. You would smile with him.. even knowing how many lives he was responsible for ending. Hanging with Jim, you forget he is a cold blooded Killer. I did. He is more like your retired High school history teacher Grandpa. Yep..

reply

Did I forget to mention that he is in a wheelchair, and can barely walk. He just sent me a letter last week. He says he stays in his cell more now-a-days. They make a lot of noise in the units, screaming and shouting at sports and rap videos. Plus people always want an interview. He gets tired of that. The 87 year old man can take but so much. He is in the handicap cell on the first floor (K2 Cell 132). They are the biggest and roomiest cells in the prison. The unit managers(and his white boy goons)usually keep him in the cell by himself. There is a large Ice machine just in front of his cell door. It makes some noise when working and they slam it shut when they get ice. That's annoying to him obviously.

reply

Like most of the people who come across your posts, I do not believe you.

However, I do get a very small amount of comfort from knowing that the scum bulger might be suffering in even the smallest way.

reply

If you guys want me to send a phone pic of his last letter with autographed post cards to me from Whitey, I can do that... but by now, with all the details in my post, with the sense I know you have, you should have put 2 and 2 together by now. And he is not suffering... his family and fans make sure he goes to the prison commissary every week to get all the Romin Noodles with refried been`s ,and cheese crackers he likes. And the cool aid fruit punch he drinks. He does have nightmares of all the people he killed, they haunt him at night.. he just get 3 maybe 4 hours a sleep a day. They are waiting for him in the after life. I can only speak on the "Jim" I meet in FCC Coleman USP 2, Coleman, FL 33521 unit K-2 Cell 132.

reply

you -> asshat.

reply

?????????

reply

I didn't read anything past 'Depp is a bad, bad actor.' And I got a feeling many others stopped reading when they read that ridiculous comment as well.

reply

The guy that started this topic ( I believe ) just wanted to sture up the pot with BS. I Hanged out with the real James " Whitey " Bulger, and Johnny Depp`s performance of Jimmie on a scale of 1-10 is a 9. No joke!!! Even his erie laugh at the dinner with Connolly, Morris and Stevie is dead on.

reply

People has been saying that Jerry Depp is a bad actor for 40 years now and yet he keeps making movie. They wouldn't even hire him to make movie if he were bad actor. They are even talking that Depp might win actor of the year.

reply

Actor of the year for Alice Through the Looking Glass or Yoga Hosers? Black Mass was released in 2015.

reply

I just loved the fact that he didn't do his jack sparrow/willy wonka stick like hes been doing for the better part of 10 years ( some exceptions of course) and I might be mistaking but is this the first time he has played a straight up bad guy?

reply

Got a good feeling.

reply