MovieChat Forums > Superstars of Dance (2009) Discussion > which three judges would you want to sac...

which three judges would you want to sack the most?


for me:
1-ARGENTINE
2-SOUTH AFRICAN
3-AUSTRALIAN



Grumble all you like, this is how it's going to be -Anne Boleyn

reply

I agree and in that order.... They are so pompous.

reply

Those 3 for me as well and I want to add India too. Just the entire top row of judges. The bottom row can stay.

OBAMA WON!!!! WOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

reply

after seeing his ridiculously high score on that australian guy's modern dance solo, i have to agree.



Grumble all you like, this is how it's going to be -Anne Boleyn

reply

I just found myself thinking, if he's the best contemporary dancer in Australia, that doesn't say much about them does it?

OBAMA WON!!!! WOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

reply

I was too distracted by the falling-off shirt to watch his dancing. Either put the dad-gummed thing on and button it, or take it off! I don't care which, just make a choice and stick with it.

reply

yeah, i know, that got me distracted as well. it was about to completely fall off near the end.



Grumble all you like, this is how it's going to be -Anne Boleyn

reply

I wouldn't mind if they sacked them all except the Chinese judge. He could sit there by himself with no expression and say "Ba...8" for every single dance. Why not, it's not like the judging makes sense anyway. Seriously, I mean no disrespect, (I understand that he may become the next Abbott of the Shaolin Temple) but he always makes me giggle.

The South African judge pisses me off, but he's kind of hot, so he could stick around for commentary, just to stir things up.

Closing time James...last call.

reply

"The South African judge pisses me off, but he's kind of hot, so he could stick around for commentary, just to stir things up."

^ @ sandserpent

LOL omg I totally agree! The South African judge is so sexy! It's so funny hearing his critiques


But anyway, these are the ones I want booted:

1. Ireland - seriously a 10 for Carolina because you're a "hot-blooded male" - GTFO!
2. Australia - gives low scores and doesn't even say why (I detect a hint of bias)

reply

That's funny. I would get rid of the whole top row and keep the bottom row, too.

reply

"Just the entire top row of judges. The bottom row can stay."

!!!

"Am I missing an eyebrow?"

reply

Amen!

Go níthe an cat thu is go níthe an diabhol an cat! Ní hé lá na báistí lá na bpáistí.

reply

for me:
1-ARGENTINE
2-SOUTH AFRICA
for me:


Seriously, Mayne.

1-ARGENTINE: Her constant freaking *name dropping* is annoying.
2-SOUTH AFRICAN: Yaps too damn much. Crikey, Just give the daggone score already, would'ya

Sheesh....







"Rude? Rude? If I wasn't so polite,I'd tell you, you really burn my butt!!"



reply

Are you kidding me?! What about the Chinese judge? He doesn't say anything other than the score. And does a Shoalin monk really know about dance?

reply

Give the Chinese judge a break! He probably doesn't speak much English! Why do you think they don't ask him to comment on the Chinese performances?

I think he's sweet. :3

reply

I was just going to reply the same way. I think it's clear that he probably does't speak very much English. When they had the tiebreaker vote, he sounded really awkward saying USA and had this slightly uncomfortable, shy little smile. I like him too.

OBAMA WON!!!! WOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

reply


1. ARGENTINE
2. ARGENTINE
3. AUSTRALIAN





Karla
Proud Member of TAM (Tara+Sam True Blood)

reply

I think Master Haiyang Wang is totally cool. Actually if you pay close attention to how he scores, unlike the others, he seems to score higher for the performers who really deserve it. He actually seems to have a more open mind than the other judges. He doesn't really always score eights, just most of the time.

Closing time James...last call.

reply

Yeah, no kidding he doesn't speak English; that's exactly why he should be out! All the other judges speak English. I'd rather have a rude, condescending judge who speaks English than a judge who doesn't.

reply

... that's absurd.

OBAMA WON!!!! WOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

reply

Yeah...cause only people that speak English can watch dancing.

reply

Argentina
South Africa

The others I don't mind too much.

Twilight Original # . . .(can't remember, lol. It was in in the 1000s, though)

reply

[deleted]

That tool from South Africa really gets on my nerves! He's so pompous!

Sooner or later, everyone goes to the zoo.

reply

1) South Africa - he looks like South Park's rendition of Michael Jackson
2) Ireland - I'm of Irish ancestry, but this guy doesn't ever seem to have much of interest to say. It seems like he's just waiting for it to be over.
3) China - OF COURSE people who can't speak English can *watch* dancing, but whether they're the best choice to communicate their reasoning to an overwhelmingly English-speaking TV audience is an entirely different question. I don't learn *anything* from his barking out a number.



God save Donald Duck, vaudeville and variety

reply

But do you learn anything from the South African and Irish judges, who both speak English? ;)

reply

Definitely the Argentinian judge (she's a freaking weirdo) & the Australian judge...Sometimes I think the South African judge finds trivial stuff to comment on...The rest of them are okay, I guess...

reply