Except for film clips..Garbage!



"Nightmares in Red, White & Blue: The Evolution of the American Horror Film"


*beep* writer/director Andrew Monument!
Never has a documentary on cinema made me so angry and depressed.

In fact, my 'as it happened' Twitter comments shall make up most of this review.


I was hoping "Nightmares in Red White & Blue". was not going to get too pretentious.
But John 'Psychoanalyst' Carpenter is in it after all.

Of course there are socio/political influences in and around horror films and which gave birth to many of them, but going by "Nightmares in Red, White and Blue" that's all there is about them.
Brian Yuzna was the only person here (about "Re-Animator") who said he wasn't making a statement just a fun horror film.

So American alien invasion films were all about killing off those that looked different?
Oh...*beep* off.

Plus it seems they can't make (genuinely valid and I 100% agree) deep observations about "Last House on the Left" WITHOUT slagging off "Death Wish" for not being critical or liberal enough.

Q: Want to know what"The Amityville Horror" was REALLY about?
A: That the American Dream of home ownership was fraught with demons!!
Oh...*beep* off.

Canadians can also feel free to feel insulted if they see this.
As it has no less than 3 Cronenberg, 100% Canadian productions, shown in this history of American horror.

So far you may think I'm being hard on "Nightmares in Red, White & Blue", but it did use "Evil Dead 1 & 2" as negative metaphors for general 80's excess in American society.
Well? You with me now?

And I wondered where criticism would be aimed in this documentary when 9/11 was reached.
Was it critical of fanatical followers of a medieval supernatural belief that openly embraces death more than life?
NO.
Just critical of silly American's and their paranoid fears.

And as it moves into the 2000's it gets no better.
Or less factually dubious.
"Hostel" is presented as xenophobic American fear of murdering foreigners.
Interviewees state how it says Americans will be safer staying at home!
Strange,what were all those American backroads/backwoods horror films about then?
Xenophobic fears of Americans about Americans and how its safer to stay in America?
A *beep* chimp could do better reasoning than this!

And what is this film about?
What actually does it stand for?
As it's done nothing but laugh and sneer at silly Americans and their boogieman fears of Communists and post-9/11 terrorism.
But then it has Larry Cohen says he fears his kids will live to see an American city nuked!
Silly Boogieman fears was that?

And the biggest poncy, sneering, Americaphobia idiot in a film full of them? (even Directors I like, which depresses me).
Well it's 'film historian' John Kenneth Muir.
Who? Exactly.

I'm so *beep* annoyed at this no fun allowed, up its own arse, *beep* of a supposed Horror movie documentary, I'm going to dump the turd in the bin!
Mr Andrew Monument take note and go back to the day job.

And all the film makers involved with this? Hang heads in shame.

reply

[deleted]

I do too. Plus they always give away the good stuff of movies you haven't watched yet.

reply

Don't forget about the part where they state their opinion of Ronald Reagan as if it were fact. I agree with the original post wholeheartedly.

reply

The statements about Reagan were true, not a matter of opinion, so they were fact.

reply

So Reagan, arguably the greatest American president, being compared to Freddy Krueger is truth? Typical liberal nonsense.

reply

yup. they were reaching with the ronald reagan comments, and on friday the 13th was nature vs evil lol

reply

So Reagan, arguably the greatest American president, being compared to Freddy Krueger is truth? Typical liberal nonsense.


Are you on drugs? He was unarguably the WORST American president, anyone who says otherwise has an extreme private hate for America.

reply

There were some films that I consider milestones to the horror genre that they didn't really mention (The Haunting, Creature From the Black Lagoon, Plan 9 From Outer Space, Dark Shadows (though it is a TV show, I believe it still had a big effect on horror cinema), When A Stranger Calls, Sleepaway Camp, Hellraiser, House of 1000 Corpses/The Devil's Rejects, I Spit On Your Grave, etc.) but I thought it was a good documentary overall.

Come, fly the teeth of the wind. Share my wings.

reply

The clips certainly make this worthwhile, but the commentary is a complete buzzkill. It seems like there's a horror documentary out every couple of months, and it might time for a moratorium on them — especially with this forced "context" and politicization. But I'll give this 7/10 based on the clips.

reply

Agreed.

reply

Wholeheartedly agree with the OP. I was expecting a documentary about horror films and all I got was a left-wing political rant about the evils of America.

reply

Don't forget Guillermo Del Toro, who is Mexican and Pan's Labyrinth is American only in the sense that it showed in American theatres. Unless they're referring to impact on American horror cinema, then I guess Del Toro and Cronenberg have influenced American horror, despite being Canadian and Mexican.

reply