MovieChat Forums > Raavan (2010) Discussion > The New York Times (Review)

The New York Times (Review)


This film has been designated as a Critics' Pick.

The low-caste Beera rules the forest in “Raavan,” Mani Ratnam’s richly atmospheric adaptation of the Indian epic “The Ramayana.” Though the film takes place in the present, Mr. Ratnam’s forest remains an appropriately primeval place for mythic doings, full of fog and mists and rain and Beera’s mud-painted followers (shades of “Apocalypse Now”).

Raavan (Ravana in Sanskrit), as every Indian knows, is the demon in “The Ramayana” who kidnaps Sita, the wife of Rama: king, deity and model husband (as Sita is the model wife). Early on in Mr. Ratnam’s film the question is asked: Is Beera (a gleefully hammy Abhishek Bachchan) Robin Hood or Raavan? He’s both — and more a hero in this telling, set on his turf, than is the Rama character, a cop called Dev (Vikram), who matches Beera in brutality and cunning, but not in heart.

“Raavan” has Bollywood glamour aplenty, with the lovely if occasionally dramatically challenged Aishwarya Rai Bachchan, Mr. Bachchan’s wife, playing the Sita stand-in. The real star, though, is Mr. Ratnam, a talented visual storyteller who directs action crisply and fills the screen with striking images. (One, of Ms. Bachchan’s falling body landing gracefully on a tree branch, is so good he uses it three times.)

Artful but not arty, Mr. Ratnam, whose films include “Dil Se” and “Guru,” delivers the goods: There are songs and dances (A. R. Rahman of “Slumdog Millionaire” fame did the excellent score), and an eye-popping climactic battle, between the bad-good Beera and the good-bad Dev, on a teetering suspension bridge. And that, folks, is entertainment.

RAAVAN

Opens on Friday nationwide.

Written and directed by Mani Ratnam; directors of photography, Santosh Sivan and V Manikandan; edited by Sreekar Prasad; music by A. R. Rahman; costumes by Sabyas Achi; produced by Mr. Ratnam and Sharada Trilok; released by Reliance Big Pictures. In Hindi, with English subtitles. Running time: 2 hours 18 minutes. This film is not rated.

WITH: Abhishek Bachchan (Beera Munda), Aishwarya Rai Bachchan (Ragini Sharma), Vikram (Dev Pratap Sharma) and Govinda (Sanjeevani).

source: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/06/18/movies/18raavan.html


P eople for the
E thical
T reament of
A bh-Ash

reply

Great to see such positive reviews, albeit from foreign media.

reply

We have seen again and again that Indian movie audiences operate from the position of very rigid mindsets. Certain films that succeeded against all odds did so because of populist elements in the story, notes that appealed to the much beleagured common man sensibility. Raavan would never be a success because it is written from the perspective of the "other". I am sorry to put it so bluntly but Indian audiences have not yet risen to to a very mature level--I am not saying this in relation to Raavan but to cinema in general.

reply

Indian critics need to see the movie again.

reply