It could have been really great
They had a nice plot which could have been put into better viewer experience.
Few things that killed the movie for me:
1) Songs - some movies don't have any scope for songs save background score, why don't people understand this.
2) Rain - seriously, whats with the rain? It just makes me uncomfortable...people dripping wet all the time and not covering themselves. Were they pneumonia-proof or what? :)
3) Louder dialogue and background "noise" - please, it creates tension in the real sense and not dramatic sense.
4) Aishwarya's shrieking - Abhishek is gr8 talent, and he is better off w/o this lady (in films).
5) Story - umm, lacks coherence and expects too much from the viewer...poor character development over all.
6) portrayal of lawlessness - Cops shooting indiscriminately, raping women in lockups - it might be part reality but I believe it certainly belonged to the days when Sadashiv Amarapurkar used to work in hindi movies.