MovieChat Forums > Paper Heart (2009) Discussion > Yi way overrated as is movie

Yi way overrated as is movie


From the trailer I thought she was a sincere, goofily cute girl making a documentary. After watching the movie, I see she is about as sincere (and talented) as the percentage that this movie is actually a doc--not much. The interviews could have been discussed juxtaposed to her experience, launching an interesting film, but by not delving in to the subject, as well as by throwing in a fake story about her and Cera, Yi ruined her own movie.

Her laugh is all right to hear one or two times, but when it becomes a large part of her dialog, gag. Her one shining moment of good acting was in Paris when she pretended to be upset about not being able to love Cera. Which is the main topic she should have brought out by weaving her supposed inability to love through the sets of interviews and honestly assessing what she *really* felt about love, rather than simply repeating, "But I didn't." (find love) and "I can't." What, exactly, does she mean? Does she have PTSD? Is she is a sociopath? She had ample opportunity to engage her own questions by listening and responding to the interviewees. Did she know she couldn't love Cera because she didn't look in his eyes and get a telling feeling? Because she had no butterflies or great early impressions of him, or felt complete revulsion, or what?

She just keeps grinning and offering nothing on the topic she made an entire movie about. And about her much-touted creativity. Those cutout puppets and props, and the stories they depicted, could have been created and enacted by a clever 9th grader. In that one shot of her in the first paper story, when she was moving the horses and riders over the mountains, she looks so intensely focused it's creepy. Girl. You're taking paper puppets on sticks and making them ride over a mountain. It's not Hamlet. And I wouldn't necessarily say she can actually play guitar or sing. She has creative potential. That's ok. Most of us would like to be able to do certain things better and are slowly getting there, too. But don't make the coffee till the cake is out of the oven.

And who has hip-length hair and barely ever brushes it let alone actually does something with it? Finally, and this is what really brought her down in my opinion, I read in an interview with her that she would just make things up (I'm sure in that same, high-pitched-yet-monotone voice) to *beep* with the interviewer and whatever press was present. If an artist pulls the wool over the media's eye to make a statement, that's commendable, but to do it just for laughs, much like an immature adolescent, dissolves all remaining hype about Charlyne Yi. In that context, her self proclaimed inability to love is about as interesting as saying, "You know, I don't like ketchup. Let's get to bottom of this."

Late show:
No props for telling a story about how as a kid she used to eat Nestle Quik straight from the container, after a minute thinking, "Mmmm, crunchy," but, "that was because my spit had dripped down into it. I was like, yummy, treats!" and how every time Ferguson asks her a question, she answers with a single word and then says, "What about you?" and didn't know that the place where rabbits live is called a "warren."

I don't usually rant about actors or comedians, but she was just too annoying.



reply

After 14 hours no one who likes Yi has anything to say? No one coming to her defense? All good. She is a creepy, annoying wannabe-influentual "hipster." Bleh.

reply

[deleted]

I find if very funny that you wrote your own little comment and then came back in 14 hrs and since no one responded, you had to respond to yourself.

Is 14 hrs the limit on how quickly people are randomly supposed to find you post on imdb.com and defend someone?

I don't mind her. I find her funny, not ground breaking like Dangerfield, Richard Pryor, or Seinfeld, but funny. She is what she is....why do expect something else? After seeing her in Knocked Up, I am not at all surprised about how she acted or made this movie. She is a quirky person with a different way of doing things.....so I enjoyed the movie.

I think you were making up in your mind what the movie was supposed to be before it was seen. I think you are thinking to hard about a 1 1/2 hr little movie.

I think that if you have seen her in any other role, and expecting something other than what you got, before or after the movie, you are a FOOL.

reply

Never said I was expecting anything. That's great you found it funny I responded to my own comment. I was just surprised that no one stood up for Yi and it seemed to concur with my point. Also mentioned that I don't usually rant...No overthinking here, just regular thinking it took to write what I wrote. It was just a reaction. No need to name-call.

reply

I was just surprised that no one stood up for Yi and it seemed to concur with my point.


People ignoring your long winded rant is not the same as them agreeing with you.

reply

Overrated on these boards. Definitely she's no Borat. But who else is besides him? I liked her at first, until all previously mentioned stuff. For some reason now even the sight of her irks.

reply

Hahaha, I love how you all talk about Borat as if that character is a real person? I find it weird that you compare that character to Charlyne Yi (an actress, not a fictional person). Didnt you realise that the whole point of Borat is Sacha Baron Cohen 'making fun' of his interviewees to expose their hypocracy and ignorance???????

reply

I don't get why she's in movies either. She's not cute, she's barely funny,she annoying as all hell, she can't act in a scene without that annoying grin on her face and she has the sex appeal of a lobotomized gorilla. I don't hate her, I'm just not a fan. She's just another celebrity whose famous because of Judd Apatow.

reply

What have you done?

reply

[deleted]