MovieChat Forums > Burke & Hare (2011) Discussion > Same plot as 'I sell the dead'?

Same plot as 'I sell the dead'?


http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0902290/

Looks very similar?

reply

Burke and Hare were real people, and they weren't graverobbers.

reply

Actually they started out robbing graves; then moved onto murdering people.

reply

No, Burke and Hare never robbed a grave in their lives. Their first 'victim' was Auld Donald who died in his sleep while staying at their boarding house. He died owing them £3 in rent so they sold his body to the medical school where they got £7 10 shillings for his body. After this another man fell ill at their house but didnt look to be dying so they decided to help him along by smothering him and again selling his body. After that they killed for their bodies.
A lot of the confusion over graverobbers comes from Robert Louis Stevenson's short story 'The Body Snatcher' written not too long after Burke's hanging which is about grave-digging ressurectionists - after this the two stories became entangled.

reply

yea few people know the sinister reasons why it was a good reason Grey Friar's Bobby gaurded his masters grave.




reply

No they did not !
Not even once.

Unlike the film a Trial did take place on the 25th Dec 1828 in Parliament Hall. Hare was a witness for the Crown. He freed himself in doing so and therefore killed Burke too. The two women in involved one Scots the other Irish were freed. Burke gave two interviews while in prison, saying that he and Hare murdered around 16-18 people. {He did not keep records or a list of the order of those killed}
Both are similar but in a different order, he strongly denied being a grave robber. It's true that the first died owing rent money the second helped to die earlier and then the others followed. The first body was carried to find a surgeon but they met a student of Dr Knox who directed them to Dr Knox's door.
Daft Jamie was well known in Edinburgh's West Port as was a young beautiful prostitute, so lovely was she that her dead body was sketched. This still can be seen today. Burke's body was dissected his skeleton is still on view and his skin used to make a wallet.
There was in fact no evidence against the men none of the bodies had any violence done to them. Knox was 'Brilliant' but his body was disfigured and the man was often ridiculed by children. What happened to Knox could easily have happened to any surgeon of the time.
There but for the grace of God !

It's also true that the doctors had a lot of bodies and yet only a very few were available legally. "SO WHERE DID THE REST COME FROM"?

This was going on everywhere and not just in Edinburgh.
Result the law was changed.



Up the close and doon the stair
Ben the hoose wie Burke and Hare
Burke the butcher Hare the thief
Knox the man who buys the beef.

Love film love cinema keep the suits at bay.

reply

Reminds me of the 1959 British movie, Mania (US title), with Peter Cushing, an academic doctor at Edinburgh University in the early half of the C19th who doesn't seem to care where the corpses he orders for his anatomy lectures from two rogues are coming from.

reply

um you werent there so you dont know the burke and hare truth
just passed along accounts of what might have happened
enjoy the movie

reply

This is based on a true story. Many films have been made about the burke and hare murders, but i believe this to be the first comedy! Can't wait. "They're making a killing!" love it.

reply

[deleted]

Assuredly not -- "I Sell the Dead" involves the supernatural. But it's a lot of fun.

reply

I'm glad you shared the name of this other film. While watching Burke & Hare, I thought I'd seen it before. But, unlike Burke & Hare, this other one was not at all funny. Burke & Hare had some good likes and jokes.

reply