a closed book


I'd like to know why IMDB promote a film where some of the crew are still waiting to be paid These films where the producers have reneged on their contracts with the crew should not get free publicity

reply

I write as a Ruiz fan keen to get a copy of the recently announced DVD release of this film. Look, if what you say is true (and it wouldn’t surprise me one bit the way things have gone in 2009), then it's obviously bang out of order to those crewmembers. But surely IMDB's role is to catalogue any film which gets released - how are they to know the legal and ethical ins and outs of each production? Moreover, unpaid crewmembers might actually be happy to receive at least an IMDB credit for their troubles - after all, it's promotion for them too.

reply

Have you ever tried to get a movie listed on IMDB. I did, and no matter how much I jumped through their bloody hoops, none of the submissions was enough to get them to list the flic. With all the information they want from people's submissions, they should themselves delve deep enough to be aware that a crew hasn't been paid.


reply

It's not that difficult to get a title accepted on IMDB, I've found. I've actually got them to list about 20 of this director's films - mainly rare pre-1990 stuff but also the occasional new production (including A CLOSED BOOK when it was still known as BLIND MAN'S BLUFF). IMDB usually asks me to resubmit each title 2 or 3 times with additional info. But they've never asked about crew payment - probably too murky an area for them to get involved with?

reply

Agreed. The producers of 'Human Traffic' did the same thing to us. It did relatively well too - so there's no excuse...

Looks like I picked the wrong day to quit shooting smack...

reply

Don't you have legal recourse? Especially if your name is listed in the credits as part of the crew?

Revenge is a dish that best goes stale.

reply

Why was this clunker released?
Shame on those who gouged others!

reply

HuH! IMDB lists (supposedly) all films that are released. Some of the films listed probably haven't been seen by more than 100 people. In any case, I don't think it is their duty to not list a movie because of some legal or work related problems. In this case though the lack of payment to the crew could have been noted somewhere on these pages. Although not trivial they could have put it in the "Trivia" section.

Don't employees have recourse through their union, FTC (government workforce complaints), or through the courts?

****************************************
My favorite: "Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb"

reply