MovieChat Forums > Hanyo (2011) Discussion > The wife wasn't that bad

The wife wasn't that bad


I sort of felt sorry for the wife - she wasn't particularly nasty to the maid - she even said 'thank you' once while she was serving her while she in bed.

I didn't particularly empathise with the maid's character so I guess because I didn't feel any emotional connection to her struggle or situation, the film fell flat for me on that level.

In the end, this is a film that has a love affair - the triangle relationship and the consequences of it - sort of feels like you've seen this thing before.

reply

it was the morning after the wife wouldn't have sex with her hubby and so he went and molested the maid that she says "thank you". it felt like she knew what had happened and was thanking her for taking care of the hubby's needs.

also she was pretty snotty about asking the maid to go hand wash her underwear.

reply

She didn't know! She was thanking her for bringing her something. She definitely didn't know that the maid was being a whore.

reply

I also agree that the wife was not that bad. She wasn't bending over backwards to be nice to the maid but she was courteous. That's what a professional relationship is in my opinion. Someone brought up the fact that she made the maid hand wash her underwear and that was nasty of her. I saw it another way. Expensive underclothes can't just be thrown in the washer, as they're made out of delicate materials. They must be hand washed. Part of a house maid's job is to do the washing. So expecting her to do this task isn't asking too much. Yeah its a little weird but no one asked her to wash the underwear with her bare hands. That's what rubber cleaning gloves are for. This is just my opinion of course. Not trying to attack anyone for their own! :)

Don't be ridiculous! Jack would never die without telling me

reply

But you know conspiring to kill the maid's unborn child was not right. Yeah I understand she was upset but killing the maid's unborn child was cruel especially if the wife is a mother herself? Do u think that was justify to kill an innocent kid because of an affair? Anyone agree?

reply

celticank88, I do agree with you on that. Although, it was mainly the mother of the wife who pushed for all these actions to be taken. It was her that pushed the housemaid and her that planned all the sick stuff they did after that. The wife was no angel in that she never tried to stop any of it but I think if the wife's mother hadn't pushed so hard none of it would've happened. Again though that's only my opinion.

Don't be ridiculous! Jack would never die without telling me

reply

That's my point aquaprincess despite that the wife was no angel she had the choice to stop her mother and its ironic for the wife's mother because how would she feel if someone did that to her but than again the wife's mother was possibly psychotic. I mean killing an unborn child would probably be under a category between pure evil and psychotic. You think?

reply

Wow i would hate to be stuck living with your idea of a good person! How is her behavior excusable at all? A "good" person would have ran up on her and said "biatch, i know what u did now get the *beep* out of my house!" not gone out to buy poison and put it in her fridge on the DL mixed with her "herbal medicine" with the express purpose of KILLING her unborn child. That's crazy, what's wrong with people? giving her money for an abortion is pretty presumptuous and awful, but not surprising and "not that bad". again, poison and forced abortion (i have a feeling they were tying her tubes in there too...) is really unthinkable. and what's up with calling her a whore all the time? the husband initiated (in a really terrifying and traumatic way i might add)and if she'd said no, guess what? she probably would've been raped and thrown out anyway! Like the mom said, when he wants something he gets it, no matter what since the time he was born. smh...what world do people live in?

reply

Still Luarela what they did was really outright cruel. I mean the wife was pregnant for crying out loud, and she went along it despite she was a mother herself. That was wrong with the wife, she went along with it and her husband was at fault, still what was done was wrong and cruel. Would you seriously do that do someone?

reply

Oh whatever. You sleep with someone's husband while they're *beep* employing you, you get what's happening. They were too kind.

reply

I totally agree with you. In what world is it okay to slap around your hired help when that person is cowering on the ground? Then make them a virtual prisoner at your house (the security guards who brought her luggage back in and took her cell phone)? And let's not forget ATTEMPTED MURDER, which the wife knew about ... was it cool for the maid to sleep with the husband? Of course not. Is it okay to KILL someone? Force feed them poison? Take their baby when all they want is to be left alone to raise the child (she said she didn't want their money)? I mean, I'm about as pro-choice as they come, and it was absolutely DISGUSTING to cause an abortion in this way. I was basically screaming "DON'T DO IT!!!!" at my tv.

I also agree that the husband initiated sex in a very disturbing, forceful way, and I have little doubt he would have either raped her or had her fired if she resisted. He ordered her to give him a BJ. She kept saying she was scared and terrified, and he ignored her.

Anyways, I don't know what crazy-ass vigilante world these posters live in, but I would be terrified of being their significant other. Makes me glad I'm single:/

They're coming to get you, Barbara!

reply

The maid confessed that she was waiting naked for him and enjoyed what happened (even tried to get his attention after the first by wearing makeup). I thought she was saying she was scared during the second scene because he was obviously about to ejaculate inside of her when he said he wouldn't. I don't understand how either of the characters overlooked that occurrence (the ejaculation) after it happened unless both were far more drunk from that wine than I thought. Idk.

reply

Well said Luarela. The comments about the underwear on here....tragic, sad and kind of ironically hilarious in a painful way.

reply

Agree about the undies. Some things should be handwashed or they'll be ruined; a wealthy family like that no doubt has expensive (and delicate) clothes that cannot be tossed in a washer and dryer.

reply

The wife was a pushover, not evil until baited and pushed to the brink of desperation, now her mother on the other hand is an evil sociopath.

If I were the wife I'd take the kid and leave away from that destructive life and divorce the bastard and bask in his alimony, I wouldn't hurt nor scorn the mistress(she may be a dumb inconsiderate bra-less bimbo but he was the one who started it) but instead I would warn her that a man who cheats on his seven-months pregnant wife will cheat again and screw over the next woman even worse and I'd tell her good luck keeping his attention with a huge pregnant belly and to consider hiring a male nanny.

Jacks

reply

I sympathized with the wife; even though she was a spoiled housewife. I've seen women in her position, first hand, and it's a miserable life when your husband has children outside the marriage. The men are usually arrogant about conceiving the child as it's "their child", so you're always the outsider. Too, bad luck if the mistress is shameless and likes to throw the pregnancy or the kid in your face every chance she gets like my uncle's mistress did to my aunt. All you want is for the bitch and the kid to disappear. I watched my aunt suffer through the embarrassment and pain of her husband [shamelessly] conceiving a child outside the marriage and I don't judge any woman who takes desperate measures.

reply

Suriname86 I am not trying to be rude or anything but it was still wrong to do that! But would your aunt would seriously consider killing an unborn child in the process? Because I do not see how that would be considered a "desperate measure", if someone was telling me to kill my spouse's mistress's baby, I tell them no because I honestly would live with myself for that and the wife at the end looked like she lost her marbles at the end. Does anyone at least agree with me that killing someones unborn kid was and is wrong and not a desperate measure? Anyone at least feel that way?!

reply

None of those women realized the husband was just a selfish prick??


Jesus would support Universal Health Care

reply

Agree!

reply

The wife was not bad, just because she was courteous to the underlings, except for the poison and almost killing with a golf club?

I would want her to thrash the husband, force him to apologize to the maid and wife, give alimony for his child and force him never to see the maid again. Then, she could be said to be not so bad.

reply

Well her thank you was just once but overall she didn't think much of the housemaid. She actually had very low opinion of her. When the wife realized her husband cheated she was not just upset. She was upset and said "How can you do it with a person that washes MY underwear." A whole lot of class consciousness and nastiness. She also should have taken it out on the husband when the issue arose but she first chose to beat the housemaid taking advantage of her helplessness. And of course there is the secret poisoning. That's pretty brutal.

reply

I didn't think the wife was horrible either. I do think that she was pushed, and brainwashed by the mother. She should have been bitter, and had a right to be bitter but her actions toward the maid, and the acts of vengeance were unwarranted. They both should have conspired against the husband together.

I do think the maid was 100% wrong. And what she did to the little girl at the end of the movie made her just as wrong in her eyes. She was kind to the child, knew the child had already been injured after the mom pushed her off the ladder, and yet, she chose to scar her emotionally, as revenge toward the parents. What did the little girl do to deserve it? the maid welcomed the husband's advances, and made it clear that she wanted him so she was no innocent party. The victim here was the wife, who then becomes the villain in the end. If you like this Korean movie, watch "Love in Between (Du yeoja on IMDB)", that one was a good movie, and had pretty much the same theme and is also set in Korea, but was much much better executed, and you end up rooting for the right people in the end, no matter who you root for.

reply