Underwhelming Lead


The strengths of the film: good period detail, interesting setting and a strong performance by Heath Freeman are mostly undone by a dull, uninteresting performance by Shiloh Fernandez. It isn't believable that his character is this brilliant writer who everybody seems to like and think is destined for great things. Nothing much he says is particularily noteworthy or charismatic. For those comparing this to "Adventureland," it's not even close. "Adventureland" is light years more enjoyable and a much better film.

reply

I agree that nothing much he says is particularly noteworthy or charismatic, but that's a script problem, not his fault... It's an underwhelming script. He wasn't given much to work with. Heath Freeman stole the film, but since he wrote it as well, maybe he deliberately gave himself the juicier part?

... and yes, Adventureland is so much more accomplished that to compare the two is an insult.







Born when she kissed me, died when she left me, lived whilst she loved me

reply

He reminded me of a lackluster Joaquin Phoenix.

reply