MovieChat Forums > Our Family Wedding (2010) Discussion > It's my turn now...I will declare this m...

It's my turn now...I will declare this movie as racist.


Haha, sorry. I've been wanting to do this for a while once I found out about this movie. So where are the white cast members? There hasn't been any controversy over this, yet every time anything from magazine covers to television commercials to movies doesn't have the "acceptable" amount of black people, you'd think the universe just exploded.

I'd just like to point out, that not only should that go both ways if people continue to insist upon "diversity" but the fact that it always seems to be a color issue. Diversity means more than just including black people in things with white people...yet I don't see a big push to include Asian people in everything.

I personally don't feel a need for all this diversity nonsense, because if someone's right for the job, they will get that job in today's world. Anyway, without rambling too much, I'd like to see if anyone else feels this way:

Does anyone get miffed that everything is a double standard anymore? As in we have BET but no WET. We have the NAACP awards, but no White Delegation awards. There was controversy over a Vanity Fair cover which talked about 10 promising actresses (all of whom were white) but yet Jet magazine and other black publications aren't even mentioned. So basically what I'm asking here, is anyone sick of the double standards? I sure am, but I'm even more sick that race is still an issue...but until it's no longer an issue, I'm going to be vocal over the double standards that occur just about every day.

reply

[deleted]

Seriously? Do we even have to go there?

reply

*yawn*

reply

[deleted]

you really don't need to correct my grammar. I'm passing all my college writing classes just fine, but thanks for looking out! But in all seriousness, unless you have something educated or opinion based to provide to this topic, don't waste your time. This is a discussion, not another pointless "RACIST" thread.

No but this is what I'm talking about. No one cares about this issue from a white person's perspective. I don't seriously think this movie is "racist" but I'm trying to bring up the argument that it seems like a non-issue, but if this movie had an all white cast, I'm sure you'd hear about that in the media. My only point is, does anyone else see the double standard? I'd just like for everything to be a non-issue, but since it isn't when involving "injustices" towards blacks, I just need to point this out.

reply

A double standard? So one out of 129024902 movies doesn't have an all white cast? Well boo frickin' hoo!

reply

Since you're in college, I'll put it into terms you can understand?

Were you able to find any White ONLY Scholarships to apply for? Or were you able to get ANY scholarships?

Want to graduate debt free? Here's a tip: When you apply for a scholarship, if it asks for race, "accidentally" check the African American box and write the essay like you're illiterate. I'm talking GUARANTEED FUNDS. You'll get money for your education, room and board, and even your books!

You may not even need to apply for a scholarship. Just check that AA box in the college application (the app fee will be waived of course) and they'll pay YOU to come to there school...and throw in a car.

reply

I'd like to see the documentary where you convince someone to do that and that's how it all worked out.

I can agree that when i went to college, or when I tried to, I couldn't find any scholarships but my black friends sure could. They also got awards for doing what I did, while being black. Every one of them got an award senior year for something at some Black Award ceremony. It was so odd, and not properly motivational. It's not like any of them were the best at the subjects they got awarded for. If I were them I think I'd be uncomfortable with such an award based on the color of my skin.

I think it's ridiculous, but I am not going to say this movie is racist for having no main white characters just like I'm not going to say the show Friends was racist for that one fact. Sure I'd like to see more diversity, but I'm not going to waste my time trying to figure out who is more racist. No one and no company or studio or style of film or whatever is perfect. I get why a Tyler perry film or whatever would try to hire as many black people as possible, but I think it's kinda sad that they feel they have to segregate themselves from others like they agree we should be separate but equal. I'd like to see more tv shows and films with a cast that looks as mixed as the reality I see, but of course, not everybody lives in a diverse area like me.

reply

@DisturbedPixie

You're obviously full of s***. There are scholarships for everything under the sun. I know you are because you didn't mention ONE damn thing you were doing to prove that YOU were smart/good enough to get a scholarship--sounds like you're just talking some bull**** antecdotal evidence. Did you know EVERY black student in that college well enough to see ALL of their reports cards and grades? I know damn well you didn't. Plus you have to have the best damn grades to even GET a scholarship---nobody just HANDS one to you! How the hell do YOU know that they're weren't the best at what they were studying in? FYI, that's what Black Award ceremonies do---they give awards to the best,talented and brightest of black students. Obviously you didn't even bother to go and see what the hell the awards were about, so how the hell do you know it's not motivational (because it is,just so you know.) You should've taken your whiny,probably-not-all-that-great-a-student-to-begin-with and-that's-why-you-didn't-make-it-but you'd rather-hate-on-the-black-students-instead-of-the-white-students-who-passed-you-up-too a** to one if you really wanted to know what they were about.

Ever heard of "legacy" admissions? That's when you're able to get into a college because your parents or grandparents not only went there but were big financial contributors to said college. Up until the 20th century, it was ONLY white people who benefitted from this privilege. Basically, it's affirmative action for white folks, and always has been---mainly because they made damn sure nobody BUT them could go to college. Black people have had affirmative action (which we also FOUGHT for,BTW) for barely 50 damn years, and white people will b!tch about that in a minute, but y'all never say s*** about your own damn legacy admissions, because it benefits YOU. 'Nuff said,gotdammit!

reply

@defucter

What a stupid,ignorant and racist post. That is not even how AA works, but since you're too damn lazy to actually do the research on it, never mind--I'm not doing it for you. Just STFU with your stupid a**. OH,and BTW, white people have always had their own AA---it's called legacy preferences---look it up.

reply

Dawnmuse79: Every post you have made on this website (use Google) shows how big of a racist and stupid redneck you are. There are so many racist ramblings that I should write about you in a blog so everyone can see what I see.

reply

I'm on your side Fly. I can't tell you how many times I used that BET/WET example. Lol, and I thought it was so original coming up with that one. But hey...when two complete strangers come up with the same example on their own...that's when you know it's a good point and it has to be made!

Racism is like unions...they were necessary for their time and helped the country progress a great deal, but now they're just used and abused. 98% of the time, it's the card that someone pulls when he or she doesn't have the brainpower to convince themselves that THEY'RE the problem. I'm not saying that there isn't racism out there, nor am I saying that unions are 100% useless...but honestly...most of the time they're called, it's someone crying for mom when somebody called them a dummy for eating their own buggars.

reply

I think it's hilarious that I have people like michaelflatley who can't compose an intelligent thought or sentence in 4 lines of writing, and yet he's calling me "stoopid." I know more people (especially outside imdb) share the same thoughts as you and I, so I'm happy about that. Anyway, I don't like to pull the race card, but when I saw this movie, I immediately thought of all the times it was pulled by someone of color if they didn't have their way. I believe Spike Lee complained about Letters to Iwo Jima? So I thought it'd be interesting to flip this to see if anyone would hear it from the point of view of a white person. (and even though this wasn't a serious thread, most people on here don't seem to think the white side of the argument is a valid one or one that should be valued.)

Anyway, it's good to see someone here actually sees what is really happening in today's society. You're right, racism has been completely abused and doesn't actually accomplish anything now, other than being a constant reminder that not everyone is the same and let the controversy build from there. I just wish more people would actually read what I have to say and see it from my point of view, rather than the one they were taught to believe in overly democratic school systems or through the media.

reply

michaelflatly is a known troll. Don't take anything he says seriously.

reply

haha, okay. I'll make sure not to then.

reply

One must realize that these issues are deep rooted from many decades of racism primarily against blacks. Whites and blacks have been together for a very long time through slavery and a lot of other racial situations. One must look at history to decipher what is right and wrong. Its much more deep rooted as mention above.

reply

God forbid a minority casted movie does not include a whites, who by far are the largest majority in the biz, god forbid everytime a movie like this is made, it is flowed with constant negativities from idiots, if you really wanna complain how many movies shine minorities in negative light in comparison to whites that's an issue not who plays what...and I'm white. If you are intelligent enough to declare a double standard then surely you must be intelligent enough to know the history of this biz and the world we live in. As for the asian thing, gee how many studios will make a lead an asian actor, when scripts don't include a nationality 9 out of ten it goes to a white male so don't give me that "push" crap. Honestly people you don't like make your own films tell your own stories.

reply

skylanbrooks, I understand how that argument is a popular one to make, but honestly I no longer think it's a valid excuse. How many black people today are slaves or legally segregated? None. I'd argue to say the majority of blacks in America today were born after the segregation days, and that no blacks alive today were alive during slave times. So why are we still using these as examples when they occurred many many years ago. That would be like me going to England and demanding money for damages during the Revolutionary War. If you didn't live during that time period, it should not be a problem for you, period.

jrmyecomp28, I'm not trying to created a new argument here, but white people are not the majority in Hollywood, Jewish people are. And if you want to get technical, which I pretty much am, Jewish people are of middle eastern descent, so couldn't be considered white by true technical terms. The whole Asian thing was more referring to commercials, which I'm sure you've noticed rarely exclude black people anymore. If you see a commercial, like an olive garden commercial, they find a way to include a black person because, like you (i assume) they are fearful of being labeled as racist, so whether it's a white family eating with a black family, a black family and a white waiter or a white family and a black waiter, I hardly see commercials nowadays that don't have black people in them. However, this is where my point comes in, do you see as many Asians included in commercials as you do black people? Since when are black people the most important minority? If a commercial needs to include a minority, all I'm saying is they shouldn't always have to be black. Same thing goes for the NFL. If anyone knows anything about the Rooney Rule, it's that NFL owners are required to interview 1 black candidate if they are looking for a coach. Last time I checked there aren't any Asian head coaches in the NFL, so why isn't there a rule that requires owners to interview 1 Asian candidate? All in all though, I don't think any such rules should exist. If someone is right for the job, I'm sure they'll get an interview regardless of their race.

The fact of the matter is I do understand the world we live in. And as hateful as people like yourself may see these comments, they really aren't. It's a matter of a flawed society where white people feel they need to make up for slavery and segregation days, when, if you truly think about it, we don't. Were you a slave owner or a white guy at a diner harassing black customers in the 60's? I'd assume not, and neither was I, so why should we be forced to suck up? Black people do as much as they can to be different from the rest of society. I'm not saying all feel a need to act out, but how many times have you seen an incident in public involving a black person? Off the top of my head I've seen 10 or more incidents. Not to say that other people don't cause incidents, but maybe there's a reason people view black people the ways they do. I personally find it hard to ignore these differences, since it's such a blatant attempt to be different from anyone else. I'm not saying they shouldn't have their own identity, but anyone who really thinks (instead of trying to be an overly accepting person) will know that they don't act as civilized as white people do. That can actually be factually supported. If you're really interested in knowing why exactly I said that, look up any study regarding people in jail, or anything regarding dangerous cities. You'll find that the majority of people in jail are black and the places in the U.S that are the most dangerous typically have a large black population.

I personally give everyone a chance to prove what kind of person they are before I write them off, but this really has more to do with the double standards and feeling by many people such as yourselves that white people must go out of their way to make black people feel accepted. But if you honestly want to know the truth, they don't want to associate with us. That's not to say that we can't have black friends, but from what I've seen they prefer being around other black people, and that's who they're comfortable being with. How many black people go out of their way to be friendly to you? I'm going to answer this honestly for you and say zero. If you have any black friends they were probably co-workers or someone you went to school with, otherwise I bet you hang out with white people just like they choose to hang out with black people.

In short, why are we so uptight about someone making a statement against black people, even though it wasn't filled with hate? We defend them all the time, when we really don't need to. Why are people still trying to make up for 2 events in history that most of us had no part in?

reply

this THREAD is full of FAIL

reply

you're a failure, and you wasted your time making a post no one will give two $hits about.

reply

Sorry, but totallyfly, how can you speak for most black people when you are not black yourself? I am black and have many white friends that I DID NOT meet at work or school. You need to know what you are talking about before you judge.

Also, all black people do not try to stand out or make themselves different because we ARE different. Period. Can you change the race that you are? Can you change the color of your skin or the heritage that you came from? No! So I really don't understand the point that you were trying to make.

No you and I were not around during slavery or the days of segregation, but that does not mean that racism no longer exists. There is no need for you to feel "White Guilt" (if you don't know about that term, please look it up). However, it would be conscientious of you to recognize that Blacks DO NOT always get treated equally, even in a post-Obama world.

As for the whole "why aren't Asians being included" thing, I don't know. Why don't you as Asian people about how they feel about that. I am sure that they would love to see themselves better represented as well. But the reason why Blacks tend to be more vocal about how they feel about the way Whites have treated them or excluded them, is because there is so much built up animosity from things that have happened from the past.

Our parents and grandparents have passed on stories of discrimination, and although things are different today many Blacks are still dealing with the effects of slavery and segregation. One could even argue that our school systems are still somewhat segregated. You mentioned that the high crime areas are mostly Black and that mostly Blacks are in the prison system. Perhaps this is also the result of a poor educational system and a lack of funding put into all of these high crime areas that just so happen to be saturated with Black people. This is not only a race issue, but a class issue. Studies show that poor areas have a high rate of crime because people are more desperate to do illegal things for money.

I am interested to see what else you have to say on the subject. It seems to me that you haven't had a real honest dialogue with a real Black person in a while....

reply

Seriously, the OP is a douche. How many movies out there have all whites casts? For how many years have they been the majority? And you want to complain??
Hispanics/Lationos never get recognition and there aren't many movies that depict a realisistic view. Of course one mexican family isn't the representation for every hispanic/american family, but it's a start.

Black people always have recognition.But look at how long they've worked for it. They have been in more movies than latinos. Now we have a movie that os funny and with latinos and people like th OP want to complain. Its time that people recognize us and stop leaving us latinos/hispanics out.

A little note. On the 2010 census there is no hispanic/latino for race.
proves my point.

reply

I agree with you lil cubanita13, except for one thing. On the 2010 Census, question 8 does as if you are "Hispanic, Latino, or of Spanish origin". This question was asked separately in order to "plan and administer bilingual programs for people of Hispanic origin". The only problem with that is that it seems they are assuming that most if not all Latinos in America do not speak English. How insulting is that? Talk about stereotypes...

reply

lil cubanita, i won't spend much time at all responding to your post, not only because you have me so badly misplaced as a "douche", but because of the disrespect you showed towards my view of things. If you want to see a douche bag, i highly recommend www.hotchickswithdouchebags.com. For a better representation of who I am, strip down the goofy behavior, tattoos, stupid facial hair, sunglasses indoors and spray tans. The only thing I do that could even be considered as a "douche" trait would be that I lift weights and exercise to stay healthy and improve who I am, and wear the occasional graphic t-shirt, but because I like the design. So there's your view of who I am, thanks for the time of your response. Make sure next time you know who I am before you jump to conclusions mat.

kami-c. I will try to answer your post as best I can, as I cannot see your post at the same time as I am writing this.

-I'm glad you don't judge people, and are friends regardless of skin color. I give everyone a chance regardless of who they are (though admittedly I'm hesitant with some people based on the way they carry themselves...i.e a shady looking guy with a trench coat...sorry, got to keep myself safe, and I'm unwilling to risk said safety if I deem the person may be dangerous. I'd like to think I'm a decently good judge of character) But honestly, I do know what I'm talking about. I wouldn't form an opinion this strong without a reason. I understand there are exceptions to rules, and you seem like a nice person, but unfortunately, and even you can admit, there are a lot of bad eggs that ruin it for people like you.

-I understand that you're different because of the whole skin thing and a few other physical differences, but how different does that really make someone? Doesn't mean they have to act differently than everybody else. Sorry to say, but if you've ever seen south park, the best way I can describe it to you (and no, this didn't form my opinion) is the way Chef explained it to Mr. Garrison when black people came up with some form of slang, and white people would copy off that slang, so black people would try to stay ahead of the white people as far as slang went to create that separation between whites and blacks. As long as black people feel a need to continue to separate themselves from white people, that's all there will be...separation. I just wish people wouldn't try to distance themselves from one another, and everyone could get along. But there is so much of a gap between people like myself, and the typical thug wannabe that I'm speaking about. No, not every black person does this, but it's obviously common enough that I would mention it.

-I don't understand where I said racism no longer exists. It surely does, but the way I see it now, black people tend to be more racist nowadays than white people are. (Though there are still racist white people, clearly.) I know everyone tries to legitimize this in favor of the black population, but take the presidential election as an example. Black people had statistically low voter turnout, and the year a black man runs, the black voter turnout was huge, and I guarantee it wasn't in favor of McCain. Now in order for Obama to win, he couldn't just have black support. The amount of white supporters, and people who voted for who they saw as the best candidate was very high. I'm really curious as to how many black people voted for McCain. I know no black let alone a guy that's partially black has ever been a major candidate for president before, but there were so many things wrong with that election. (for the record, I don't care for politics and think the majority of the government is out of touch with the American public)

-I don't think I've ever seen blacks being excluded from anything. If anything there has been inclusion of black people in nearly everything for a while. There were a ton of mostly black sitcoms in the past decades: Cosby Show, Fresh-Prince, Family Matters, Those Tyler Perry sitcoms on TBS, Sister Sister, Kenan and Kel and Moesha just to name a few. So I'm not seeing how black people still feel excluded for things. The public is embracing the black population more than ever. I don't see why there's animosity anymore. These times are the best for any minority to live in. A lot of the racism that exists nowadays is stupid, petty things, like that Rooney Rule (requiring black coaches be interviewed in the NFL) a talk show person like Don Imus "insulting" a woman's basketball team or stuff like that.

-Schools that appear to be segregated nowadays are because of the minorities (read the paragraph before you assume the meaning behind that sentence). When black students see themselves as being different from white people is when that segregation occurs. When there is that discomfort, the black students tend to migrate towards each other black students so they don't have to feel awkward. It's a shame that this happens, and I'm sure it's the same for white students in city schools where the population is mostly black. The area I'm from is unique in that there are wealthy areas, like where I went to school, and then several schools that are polar opposites just a few miles away. I've heard at some of those less fortunate schools black students harass and jump white students, and I'm sure they're in the same financial situation. I never saw any hateful acts carried through in my mostly white school. If anything the kids did what they could to make those students feel at home. I understand these city schools are in rough areas, but no one is forced to act violent, and anyone has the will power to be a good individual. I see that there is a difference, but I'm a no excuses kind of guy. I was always told never to make excuses when I was younger, as I used to think I should get a pass pertaining to me being smaller than a lot of people. I eventually learned to do everything I could to get stronger and never make excuses for myself again. So there's no excuse to act violently.

I appreciate your side of the argument, but this is just the way I see things, and I think anyone that truly reads this long post will find many points to agree with. I by no mean think every single black person is bad, and in fact my frustration comes from the the media or whoever is involved insisting on never letting the race issue die. Since it's being kept alive and well, I felt this was an opportunity for me to express my view of the situation and the problems this truly causes towards never letting the race issue die. I understand there's a long history of black people being treated the way they were, but I want to go from black people, white people, mexican people, asian people to just "Americans"

reply

[deleted]

It seems to me that you are coming from a baised pointed of view. I do respect your opinion, I just feel that you will never understand our situation fully because you are not Black. Although you say that you judge people on an individual basis you are still making generalizations about people based on a few incidents (like the one you mentioned about blacks attacking white at a high school). Furthermore, how could you use an example from "Southpark" to make a point about what Black people feel? "Southpark" does NOT speak for Black people. I'm also tired of people complaining about the Obama election. The president is Black, ok. Why the whining? It's not the end of the world. I also think it is interesting that you are blaming the segregation on the minorities. We didn't start it. Yes some prefer to stick to their own, but that is because they have been made to feel uncomfortable (most likely by someone of another race/class). Lastly, I don't appreciate being referred to as, "people like you". I thought I was an

?

reply

-The mention of south park wasn't an example, but rather just the best way to tell you about what I was speaking about. I couldn't think of a good way to explain what I was trying to say, so I thought that would clear things up.

-The president is half black and half white to clear things up.

-I'm unsure you read the segregation being caused by minorities thing very well. This could refer to black students in a mostly white school or white students in a mostly black school. White students in a mostly black school are the minority as well.

-And when people start worrying about really vague statements such as "people like you" is when problems start. First off, I don't know where I said it or how I said it, second of all I guarantee it wasn't used how you think it was. If I said it, it was probably referring to politically correct people (which I think political correctness is one of downfalls of free speech) So don't get upset over that.

reply

I'm not upset, just felt that my intelligence was being insulted. And yes, I know that Obama is biracial...Why did you feel the need to mention that? Regardless, it is obvious that you have some issues with Black people. The fact of the matter is, your original post was a setup to start a never ending dialogue and push your own agenda. We can go back and forth about this forever, but I choose to leave you off with this cliched statement: "Never judge a book by it's cover." Although overused, it is a true statement. One can only hope that an enire race of people will not always be judged based on a few negative incidents (this goes for any race, not just Black people).

Peace and Love.

reply

Like i said before, everyone gets a chance to prove what kind of person they are.

Peace and Love.

reply

Kami, well said.

I decided to read this thread because I thought it was a discussion of the overt stereotypes in the movie, rather than cleverly handling the whole divergent culture issues.

OP, I have only read about half of what you have written because it goes on and on, without a succinct point. Getting into a huff about a movie that did not included "white people" when the plot was not related to it, is so not an issue. As to BET and ethnic/racially-bases awards, so what. There are gads of awards out there for any type of special group or reason you can think of.

You know that sound Goofy makes when he falls? That's my quote.

reply

[deleted]

Jesus your post really shows how dumb texting and social media has made Americans. I can't even read your post because the language is just flat out ignorant. I rest my case!

reply

there IS a "wet" channel..its called CMT..or do u see any blacks there?

do we need to mention names of all white cast sitcoms?some of them dont even have a token black guy in them..

its amazing how such a harmless movie like this can STILL bring out the douche/troll in some people..its like they get a hard on for making people feel just as miserable as they do..

reply