MovieChat Forums > The Trotsky (2010) Discussion > How does Alexandra love Leon?

How does Alexandra love Leon?


Seriously, how does this make any sense?

reply

He has passion and commitment - that's something a lot of people can love.

reply

Passion and commitment? Yes. He has those, but he devotes them to living a fantasy.

The whole Alexandra storyline killed this movie for me. The humour and the story were fun, the cast did a good job, especially the high school kids, but the romance was too far.

They actually did a good job at first, where Alexandra dismisses Leon's advances. She brings it up once, and briefly, how Leon doesn't love her for who she is, but for a series of coincidences that have nothing to do with her being a person. This is, most of us would say, an illusion that Leon is trying to keep alive by having people come into his life to play their roles and then leave when necessary. But these aren't just characters from history coming back for his benefit. These are real people with real personalities and lives. None of that matters as long as they play the roles that Leon requires them to play for as long as they supposedly did in the past.

I'm not saying Leon is crazy and needs help. Leon is free to live his life believing he's the reincarnation of Trotsky, but Alexandra doesn't believe that she's the reincarnation of Trotsky's wife. And yet the plot requires her to fall in love with this random guy who barely knows her except some little details out of a dead man's biography. Hell, what does that say about when Leon talks about finding his second wife to her face at the end of the film?

In that regard, the movie annoyed me. And those scenes and issues made me less willing to go along with the rest of the movie because the same principles apply to his leading the schools in protest, antagonizing his father, turning his sister and class mates into lapdogs...

So yeah, ultimately this movie was a near miss for me. As funny as some of the moments were, the issues above just keep re-surfacing in my mind when I think of the film.

reply

A bit unusual to comment on a 2 year old post, but have to point out that all stalkers have a degree of passion and commitment. Thats usually why they are stalkers.
The romance in this film was seriously creepy.

reply

Completely agree. Movie was good up until the point Alexandra randomly *beep* this 18 year old weirdo. Made absolutely sense and was completely inconsistent with the movie up to that point.

reply

ugh, the rest of the movie was creepy as well. So the film-makers think it's laudatory to hold people hostage if your cause is right? There's quite a bit of question if the guy has any cause at all other than his own self-publicity.

I hated highschool. I hated the teachers and the administration. This movie had me rooting for the authorities. What a self-righteous, smug little prig this idiot is. Also, typically, Hollywood ignores the real history of trotsky and his complicity in the murder of millions of Russians and minority ethnic groups and celebrates him as a hero- someone young people should emulate.

reply

In Hollywood's defence, I do believe this to be a Canadian film.

reply

"Completely agree. Movie was good up until the point Alexandra randomly *beep* this 18 year old weirdo. Made absolutely sense and was completely inconsistent with the movie up to that point."

==She was drunk. I just watched this movie.

reply

That was bizarre, when she said she thinks she's in love. Movie magic, I guess.

Still, the rest of of it was so charming, I couldn't help but root for the guy.

reply

I know this is an old thread but I just watched the film again and wanted to comment on it. His passion and commitment and good heart are the obvious answers to the question. I can see how people might suggest that these virtues alone don't eliminate the fact that he's living his life as though he's required to follow the dictates of Trotsky's life. This is precisely why she (and nearly everyone else) believes him to be crazy early in the film.

However I think a great way to look at the way she can identify and feel compassion and affection for him is if you look at his perspective the way we think of Don Quixote. Though I doubt its done for the sake of explaining the love interest we even see a Don Quixote represented in the film by the character Skip dressing as him during the Social Justice. Just because Leon's character sees the world in a way that does not reflect reality it does not mean that his motives, actions, and good nature are flawed or at fault. In fact we find the opposite, despite his obviously flawed belief that he's the reincarnation of Trotsky his motivations and actions come out as pure and attract so many people to him.

Obviously its just a film and its easy to say "it was written in the script" as an explanation of how Alex falls in love with Leon. But I think the foundation is there in the film and hinted at several times. At least, that is my opinion.

reply

I suspect there were scenes that showed their love developing more, but were cut for time.

reply