MovieChat Forums > See prang (2008) Discussion > i disagree about the 1st and the 4th sto...

i disagree about the 1st and the 4th story...

posted 15 years ago by sik-12
18 replies | jump to latest

i just watched phobia and although I agree this aint anything new, I would still say its nicely done and not at all worn out.
the 3rd had its funny moments(when he spoiled Shutter I laughed so hard...), the 2nd was just lame and the FX pretty bad. But the 1st one and the last one really stand out. One room, no dialogue, one actress setting I found pretty well done. The fourth was just plainly scary and I totally disagree with the comment writer before, although it was obvious what was gonna happen it was still scary (i`ve seen a lot of horror flicks, dont start that...). If u like thai horror just watch it, but make sure u get to see Shutter first (the Thai version not the crap-made US version, as always...)
8/10 from me.

[–] frostorm 15 years ago

The 4th segment was indeed awesome.

"I can't believe that Bryce prefers Van Patten's card to mine..."

[–] deadraque 15 years ago

I loved the 1st one and the 4th was my least favourite, how everyone's tastes can change, for me it played in order, from Very good to good,to not bad and at last ok. To bad that the 3th segment is a ripp-off of the Series "Afterlife" episode 1 S2.

We don't live. We survive

[–] tainted_perfection 15 years ago

I liked the 1st,3rd and 4th story alot. The 2nd one was average. Not so strange for me coz my favourite stories were directed by either of the Shutter duo (which was awsome) while the 2nd story was directed by the guy who helmed Body No.19 (which i didin't like so much).

I'm ruthless...with a smile on my face

[–] 15 years ago

[deleted]

[–] 15 years ago

[deleted]

[–] ferryersa 14 years ago

XoWishingStairsoX, that's the 2nd, the one everybody talking about...

[–] 14 years ago

[deleted]

[–] castlerock20002000 14 years ago

My favorite was the third, those characters are fun! and we get to see them again in 5prang.

[–] Rogueintruder 13 years ago

The first one was dreadfully boring, and climax was nothing special. I did like the second probably the best, the fx was crap but gore was good, third was good as a comedy, fourth was average for me.

[–] jaymanalo 13 years ago

I thought the first story's the best among the four.

[–] wreckage-1 13 years ago

There were two that really stood out to me... the First for being really good (I wish it had come later) and the second for being pretty bad

[–] Radharne 13 years ago

My faves are 1st and 4th. 2 very hot chicks! =)

[–] lynseylinzlu 13 years ago

Jast watched 4bia and really enjoyed it. Story 1 was pretty creepy, story 2 was a little silly but i liked the climax, story 3 my fave cause it was funny and i was really engrossed in what was going on, story 4 was pretty creepy. I think story 4 could work better as a feature length film whereas the others worked well at the lenth they were.

[–] OldSchoolRecords 11 years ago

^^ This exactly.

I actually believe each of these shorts can be made into a feature length film, but can imagine them also becoming boring and/or repetitive. However, the 4th one with the corpse in the empty flight has a lot more potential.

[–] 11 years ago

[deleted]

[–] Leviphiliac 11 years ago

I liked how in the 3rd story they were talking about all those spoilers, and one of the guys was wearing the Spoilers shirt. And the girl of the 1st one sent an sms to one of the guys saying she hoped he would drown. Heheh.

it hurts

[–] masuka-fan 11 years ago

And the girl of the 1st one sent an sms to one of the guys saying she hoped he would drown.

And then he's mentioned in the fourth story.

"Passion is just insanity in a cashmere sweater!"

[–] spookyrat1 10 years ago

I think the first story was the best by far; the most original and the scariest.

The second was the worst; just an excuse for a blood fest.

The third was a bit different and out there with a few laughs thrown in.

The fourth could have been great, but I think was misdirected and went over the top.

Seriously a pilot cuffties an hysterical flight attendant to the floor in front of a corpse and leaves her alone. That's his idea of duty of care? I know it suited the plot but...LOL!