First of all, of-course it all happened in reality. As for the issues that this movie raises, that's a different thing. You could clearly see, that being selected as the reincarnated Lama, is indeed a great honor. Many families almost suggested that their child be picked.
The "test" that proves he is the right one - when he has to pick the previous Lama's belongings, out of a selection of similar items was very problematic in my opinion, since the Lama's beads, bell, and other things - were always the flashiest. I would guess 7 out of 10 would ultimately pick the same items.
I was not convinced that this is a demonstration of a mystical process, as much as a presentation of a cultural process, that is rare and unique.
I loved it, since it reminded me of my travels to Northern India. The kind and beautiful Tibetans, and the amazing landscapes.
I thought it lacked some crucial parts in order for it to be an excellent documentary. Although it covers the process over a few years, you still feel like some parts are missing. Many times you are left with unanswered questions - but, that's part of this film's beauty. It's clear that the movie was made by people that are close to the Tibetan culture, and have great respect for it.
reply
share
doo-buzz
14 years ago
I loved this documentary too as well as all the others being shown on the BBC's Storyville and Channel 4's True stories series. No narratives, voice overs or fancy graphics.
I don't think there was any need to go into the details and ask all sorts of questions or request scientific validation, especially when dealing with religion. For these reasons it was incredibly respectful and did not pander to the western thought process.
reply
share
forwardmarch-1
14 years ago
Really, you think a black bell is way more flashy than a shiny gold bell? Interesting. The kid said "THAT'S MINE" immediately as soon as he pulled out the beads before he even asked him anything at all. That's a common response from a reincarnated lama. Perhaps they know they are going to forget much during transmigration so they somehow force themselves to remember their belongings so that they will be recognized.
reply
share