MovieChat Forums > Temple Grandin (2010) Discussion > Who was the guy who ruined her design an...

Who was the guy who ruined her design and why. . .


. . .was he allowed to do that? Did I miss something during this movie? It was right after the reporter told her that her design was brilliant, or whatever. Please explain. Thx.

reply

Here is an excerpt from Dr. Grandin's book "Thinking in Pictures." She doesn't identify the specific person who tampered with her design:

The first thing I did was convert the ramp from steel to concrete. The final design had a concrete ramp on a twenty five-degree downward angle. Deep grooves in the concrete provided secure footing. The ramp appeared to enter the water gradually, but in reality it abruptly dropped away below the water's surface. The animals could not see the drop-off because the dip chemicals colored the water. When they stepped out over the water, they quietly fell in, because their center of gravity had passed the point of no return.

Before the vat was built, I tested the entrance design many times in my imagination. Many of the cowboys at the feedlot were skeptical and did not believe my design would work. After it was constructed, they modified it behind my back, because they were sure it was wrong. A metal sheet was installed over the non slip ramp, converting it back to an old-fashioned slide entrance. The first day they used it, two cattle drowned because they panicked and flipped over backward.

When I saw the metal sheet, I made the cowboys take it out. They were flabbergasted when they saw that the ramp now worked perfectly. Each calf stepped out over the steep drop-off and quietly plopped into the water. I fondly refer to this design as "cattle walking on water."

reply


The first thing I did was convert the ramp from steel to concrete. The final design had a concrete ramp on a twenty five-degree downward angle. Deep grooves in the concrete provided secure footing. The ramp appeared to enter the water gradually, but in reality it abruptly dropped away below the water's surface. The animals could not see the drop-off because the dip chemicals colored the water. When they stepped out over the water, they quietly fell in, because their center of gravity had passed the point of no return.

Before the vat was built, I tested the entrance design many times in my imagination. Many of the cowboys at the feedlot were skeptical and did not believe my design would work. After it was constructed, they modified it behind my back, because they were sure it was wrong. A metal sheet was installed over the non slip ramp, converting it back to an old-fashioned slide entrance. The first day they used it, two cattle drowned because they panicked and flipped over backward.

When I saw the metal sheet, I made the cowboys take it out. They were flabbergasted when they saw that the ramp now worked perfectly. Each calf stepped out over the steep drop-off and quietly plopped into the water. I fondly refer to this design as "cattle walking on water."


Thank you for the excerpt. I'm terribly excited to read this book.

Temple offered such brilliant, although relatively logical adjustments to the 'dip vat.' I was terribly impressed by her highly analytical skills, and to 'hear/see/think' without her ego interfering. This is science in it's purest form, the way it was meant to be.





More science, less fiction.

Karlrobert Kreiten--http://tinyurl.com/n938vj

reply

[deleted]

In an addition to that, the guy's a "roughneck". He's probably been working cattle his whole life. I would imagine he would not take kindly to being told everything he has been doing is wrong. Let alone from a woman. And an autistic one to boot!

reply

Not just roughneck but dead from the neck up and a Meathead to boot.

Is it any wonder there is such cruelty in the food industry?

I'm sure this Meathead has his counterparts in the poultry, pig and sheep industries.

reply

I was just coming here to ask the same thing. I wanted to slap sense into that man through the t.v for being so ignorant...lol ;)I am glad to hear that she got the last word & her plan was executed as she designed.

reply


It doesn’t surprise me that he acted that way. He went right back to doing things the way he was taught and the way they had always done it. I think a lot of people would react the same way when they’re told they’ve been doing it wrong their whole lives. That’s no excuse for changing it though, he didn’t have the authority to do that.



Just cuz u think my opinions r wrong doesn’t magically make ur’s right. Stupid trollz...

reply

Hard to say. For all you know, he may have been a supervisor with some limited discretion. The film didn't state either way from my viewing.

reply