MovieChat Forums > Jack Goes Boating (2010) Discussion > Jack Goes Boating... and audience snooze...

Jack Goes Boating... and audience snoozes?


Doesn't sound that good, that's for certain.

http://shareddarkness.com/2010/09/20/jack-goes-boating.aspx

^ Review says: "A characteristically morose wallow in indie-style shoe-gazing that should only please the most dedicated fans of the talented actor." D'oh!

reply

Meh, I thought it was great. A very tender story about adults who are still shy and vulnerable.

Philip Seymour Hoffman once again shows his love for stage as he adapts this from the theatre, and he did a great job considering it's his directorial debut.

reply

Me too. To say the least, I am very surprised at the relatively low rating and negative reviews. I gave this a solid 7.5/10.


Jack Goes.... was actually pretty clever. I docked it some for sloppy editing in places and a few issues with the script.



Life would be so much easier if we only had the source code.

reply

A 7.5 --- That is exactly what I would have rated this movie, but since that is impossible on this site, I rated it an 8 ---- On a different subject, don't you think that IMDb users Aged Under 18 should not be able to vote on, at least "R" rated movies?

reply

Yes. People under 18 don't have any intellectual or emotional depth to rate a movie
...sorry, but it's true.

reply

"Yes. People under 18 don't have any intellectual or emotional depth to rate a movie
...sorry, but it's true."

Agreed, but unfortunately that is who Hollywood caters to.


My Top 50 Films http://www.imdb.com/list/ls033211402/

reply

I thought it was ADORABLE!

Not for general audiences, though. It's a movie for grown ups...like most plays are.

Acting was superb, and the story was such an interesting mix of whimsy (Jack and Connie) and angry disappointment (the other couple) and WEIRDNESS.

reply


I thought it was very well done. Difficult to watch at times but quite poetic and touching

reply

I thought it was a pretty good movie; funny and serious at the same time. Great character study. Not every movie can be shoot 'em up, car chases and explosions all the time. The four main characters were perfect for the roles they played.

reply

Definitely enjoyed this. I had been watching a few explosive things prior to catching it so it was a welcome change to come back down to planet earth with this story and these characters.
I've got to fess up and say that I love nearly everything PSH puts his hands on so I might be biased.

reply