MovieChat Forums > Love Aaj Kal (2009) Discussion > Is this really happening in India?

Is this really happening in India?


This looks more like screw Aaj Kal desi style! Protagonists trying their desperate best to match the American teenager culture! But one question, has India really transformed to that degree, where guys are picking up girls from discos and banging them on first date and then going about their business? Or is it more a media attempt to give that impression? And to Saif, grow up bitch!

reply

Yes.

Hope that answers your question, lol.

reply

It's a shame that with movies like Love Aaj Kal and Kambaqt Ishq, men are shown to be players, and while this does happen, it is still a taboo, and gives shame to both culture and religion. This superstars are advertising this lifestyle, through which future generations will choose to be shallow without feeling guilt. What a shame.

reply

we organized a protest march in jhumritaliya against this obnoxious film which is highly against the glorious indian culture

reply

What a massive waste of time and energy.

reply

[deleted]

Well, actually..if you read his/her post, the protests were in Jhumritaliya. Not surprising because the rural areas always have and will be stuck in the mindset of 1800s. Let's see if useless protests like that fly in a modern city like Delhi. Understand this: Our culture has a history, but no doubt is one of the most repressive ones. The age old thinking, the oppression of sex, male-female relationships, arranged marriages is not getting us anywhere. It's time all those things just DIE.

reply

[deleted]

"But it's part of indian heritage, so it will take a long time."

Isn't that a kick in the nuts? For a country that calls itself the new land of opportunities, the most developed developing country this backward thinking sure is a massive setback.

reply

[deleted]

Actually, I feel that you are missing the difference between repression and respect and condemning some behavior that is simply respectful - of others and yourself. You think all those things should die? Well, I'm born and raised in the USA and I've watched this "culture" being influenced by "just" movies and the mess that we have here now is a direct result of older, respectful traditions being, not only tossed out, but condemned. You can be progressive and modern (if you're talking about technology, financial success and stability, competing with other nations, etc.) without sacrificing the good aspects of a culture. Here, we have no stability - marriage is a throw away item, children are not raised to respect authority nor to respect themselves and others, people criticize you if you do not support single women having children - I would never want to make life nasty or difficult for a single mother, but I'll never say that it's a good way to raise children either, an insignificant minority (3 to 5% of the population) has totally changed our marriage laws and are able to harass small businesses who don't support homosexuality right out of business in fact, you can be judged as having committed a crime if you speak out against it, and we have political leaders who no longer even observe the laws of our land or constitution and no one does anything about it. But heavens, yes, we're modern!

Just watch some of the American movies and wonder what it would be like to live in a culture where you hear parents talking to their children with a string of profanities or watching people who are under the influence of alcohol or drugs making stupid decisions in public and adversely affecting the lives of others who don't even know them. Then try to say something against the disrespectful treatment of others and you'll be told that everyone has the right to say anything they want or to act the way they want. If you are against abortions and say anything, you're called a "Christian" even if you aren't and it's now understood in this culture that being a "Christian" is a disgrace!

We used to have laws that TV needed to respect the "community standards" of the majority of communities where it was broadcast. But step by step Hollyweird kept "progressing" and using more profanity, showing more sex and nudity and then showing homosexuals in explicitly sexual scenes, and adding jokes to put down people who complained about any of those things. Those might be the community standards of Hollyweird, but they still are not the standards of your average community although that is changing because people continue to say, "Oh, don't be so old fashioned, it's just entertainment." So, if all our problems appeal to you, just keep trying to throw out all your standards and traditions. Obviously, I do see that there are or have been some very repressive standards in India, but it seems that little by little, they have been getting rid of those traditions that do not help the citizens of a nation - killing widows when their husbands die, having a caste system, having only arranged marriages that require dowries, etc. The fact that some of those traditions and beliefs, such as the caste system or any prejudicial beliefs, are dying slowly can hold back a nation. Poverty and lack of education will certainly damage a country, much more than arranged marriages or strict sexual standards! Just be very careful what you wish for. . .

Shauna & Ms. Phoebe, my God-given Happy Pill

reply

I do not have a problem with "American teenager culture" and its influences on India. But what I do have a problem with is, whatever the movie portrays do not happen in India. Totally impractical. It's just the escapist form of movie making-something that is rampant in India

reply

Exactly my thoughts. This movie had a script which a 3 year old would write while having a shower.

reply

I disagree.. See for one thing this movie was made with indians living in London, UK where the protagonists may have have this sort of a lifestyle so you can't penalise the makers. Also, guys this is a movie!! It's meant to be a little over the top (in other words, fantasy) so LIVE WITH IT and take it in good humour..

reply

"where guys are picking up girls from discos and banging them on first date and then going about their business?"


No..

reply

I think you are pointing in the wrong direction. You should ask the question about girls. Men were always like this, to those who talk about Indian culture and all, switch on some news channel and you'll find some rape incident on the spot, especially of Tourists who come to India.

Anyway, India is changing and so do the people.

reply

Oh! gimme me a break the so-called-messiahs of the Indian culture curry!The script, the plot everything is totally in sync with the western culture, even saif's character is totally americanized! Globalization wont give u a damn however foul u cry! Big megalomaniacs, thinking that they are are last descendants of Valmiki, holy crap! If they were really were, they wouldnt have been cribbing about the holy indian cow, on some internet forum, they would have have made it to the front pages of the media...at the ripe old age of 35. Stop cribbing. The day you stop cribbing, the world will follow you. Else not, crib away, in the online forums.

Amen!

reply

This movie just don't make any sense with 250 flashbacks that don't have anything do with that particular scene. And the plot is so embarrassing.
What are they trying to prove? That the indian culture is more like the western culture in real life? That indian girls are easy to pick up in a club in India then take here home? That saif ali khan is soon 44 but still want to act like he is 24? That the twist song will give you a headache with all the clowns, strippers, star wars characters jumping around with 200 diffrent clothes calling it dancing? That the story was written by a retard? That saif ali khan is really rishi kapoors unborn child? That SRK's and Saif's future films will always will be filmed in the U.S? That robbers in US will kick you down, punch you in the stomach and bite your hand if you don't give a picture of a girl who is unknown for him even if you already got all his money?
That bollywood just can't make movies or have not done it for the past 15 years?

reply

dude, you wrote the SAME thing at 4 different places. Get over it! It's a movie...don't like it, don't watch it.
Trust me, you'll live longer without the tension.

reply

You, sir, haven't understood the movie at all. Get a life!

reply

shangar, stop writing the same thing in all the topics.. and as someone pointed out, the movie was not half as bad as you making it out to be.. its meant for entertainment.. just watch it and if you were not enjoying it, then why did you bother watching the entire movie? and now you whining on forums about how stupid it was..grow up.. JUST A MOVIE.. no biggie.. i bet you couldnt make a movie even half as good as this..

I have to return some video tapes...

reply

I dont know in the East or West where there are *regular* amicable breakups which lead to more intense activities later....boring.

reply

[deleted]

movie was ass

reply

[deleted]

@Shangar:
The indian film industry does make Good Film...nd gud romantic 1s too

watch saif's come back movie

Hum Tum (2004)...Its got everythin needed 4 a perfect movie

Nd...y do u put sooo much or ur head into thinking bout the movie..wach ot...4get it..movies r 2 entertain....nt 2 add more tension 2 ur life..

U treat this movie as the worst movie on earth??cmon mann...
ther r so many movies...tht u cant bear 2 sit n wach them...
movie tht u regret ur whole life 4 wasting those 2-3 hrs.

Nd haan yea....those hu say tht Desi Gals r still gems...
Go into sum college in blanglore or sum place like that...
Trust me guys...we guys r decent...nd we r more indian than them

reply

LOL! Most people who reacted to this thread and the OP need to watch the film again, with an open mind and more carefully this time.

NEWSFLASH: Saif going to the party/disco and "picking up" that blonde girl was in London, not India.

reply

I was in this film. At least some of it (the scenes I performed in, which were in a beautiful building that we were portraying as an architecture firm) were filmed in San Jose, California.

reply

Wasn't that scene taking place in india? Your talking about where deepika's painting those monuments right.

reply