MovieChat Forums > En nombre del amor (2008) Discussion > My thoughts on the backstory

My thoughts on the backstory


Note: The following is pure speculation. I haven't read any spoilers that aren't already being mentioned nor have I seen the previous version of this novela.

Carlota is actually only a half-sister to Macarena and Javier. Either she is from their father's previous marriage or the result of an adulterous relationship. Javier, as the first-born (and ultimately the only) male child, was favored in terms of inheritance and education; their father assumed that Carlota and Macarena would eventually marry within their social class.

About ten years prior to the opening scene of the prologue, Cristobal briefly courted Carlota before realizing that he preferred Macarena. One night they gave in to temptation, resulting in Macarena becoming pregnant. The night this came to light, the father died, either a tragic coincidence or provoked by Carlota. Carlota siezed the opportunity to blame Macarena for his death, then sent her far away before her pregnancy began to show. She then told Cristobal that Macarena committed suicide and he left for Mexico City.

Their father's will gave generous trust funds to Carlota and Macarena as well as the family home, but left his remaining assets (possibly including a family business) to Javier.

Javier and Sagrario were married around this time (it had already been planned) and moved into their own house. A few months after they returned from their honeymoon, Macarena gave birth to a baby girl. Carlota tried to get rid of the baby, but Macarena -- with the help of a priest or a madre superiora -- arranged for her to be adopted by Javier and Sagrario. When she returned to the family home, she was told that Cristobal committed suicide just after the last time they saw each other.

Since this time Carlota has controlled Macarena with guilt while showing her best face to Javier, just as she had done previously with their father. She hated Sagrario from the beginning because Sagrario saw through her and because she "took Javier away" from her. She has hated Paloma from birth because she is a child of love... and of the man her sister "stole" from her. Also because Paloma was loved by her parents.

This is the only logical explanation I can come up with for why Carlota has such an irrational hatred of Paloma.

Anyone have anything to add to this?


The Fabio Principle: Puffy shirts look best on men who look even better without them.

reply

Venus, what you wrote is what I have been thinking all along except for one thing. You stated that the sisters' father left them trust funds. Why then, is Macarena so dependent on her sister? I've always felt Carlota has money and owns the house and that Macarena lives off of her charity.

I also think that Macarena made the arrangements for Paloma to be adopted by Javier and Sagrario, but Carlota took the credit. It is all part of the cover up. I remember in the first two episodes Javier and Sagrario mentioned how they owed a lot to Carlota. Also, when Paloma's parents were arguing in the car and Sagrario mentioned how she did not much care for Carlota, Javier reminded her that thanks to his sister they had Paloma.

I agree that Cristobal first dated Carlota and then decided on Macarena. I think it is interesting that this is exactly what is going to happen with Paloma, Romina, and Emiliano.

reply

It would be very easy for Carlota to steamroll Macarena; she's probably been doing it since they were children. If you tell a person enough times that they are stupid, incompetent, ugly, an invalid, etc, they will eventually believe it.

She treats Macarena like an idiot and trust me; I've known people whose parents and entire family treat them like this. It is very difficult for these people to have any self-esteem or confidence in their actions. For Macarena to not be handling her own money at this point is unusual, but not surprising under the circumstances.

I am wondering how Carlota will murder Inaki.

Of course history will somewhat repeat itself with Paloma, Rumina, and Emiliano. What's confusing me is how Rumina could have turned out as she did with Camila for a mother.

The Fabio Principle: Puffy shirts look best on men who look even better without them.

reply