MovieChat Forums > Kaminey (2009) Discussion > Johnny Gaddar or Kaminey...who has the m...

Johnny Gaddar or Kaminey...who has the most Kamineys..?


Both movies have interesting plots of having all the casts as scoundrels(kamineys)....but the award for having most kamineys will goto johnny gaddar..
Kaminey do have few good characters as guddu and sweety , but in johnny gaddar including the main characters (neil nitin) and even the character having minute screen presence in movie (ashwini kalsekar) is shown to be kamina in the end...
Amidst all the hype ..though most of ppl may not agree with me...i still liked johnny gaddar more ...than kaminey...
Kaminey still have the huge starcast and production value with a director having brilliant past track record..Johnny gaddar being made with considerable low budget with somewhat new starcast( except dharmendra) and director not having a formidable track record( though i feel his first movie ek hasina thi was also too good)..
Again its my view ..anyone agrees? or have some different views..?

reply

You can say that, but still deze r both two very different films,
while Johnny Gaddar is a subtle thriller, Kaminey however is an over the top crime thriller.
Johnny Gaddar had some real Kaminey characters but if you want to count the number of Kamina's in a film then for me "Kaminey" takes the cherry.

I'm Illiterate. Can i use my thumb impression?

reply

this reminds me of one more kamina movie....where everyone tries to double cross each other....RACE...howzattttt

reply

Johnny Gaddar was a far better film than the overrated Kaminay.

reply

Of course, but Gunda was obviously a better movie that either :P

reply

Kaante is the ultimate kaminey movie.

______________________________________
Give yourself time to notice rainbows.

reply



'I know the pieces fit 'cause I watched them tumble down' - Tool Schism

i agree

reply

RACE totally sucks cock...
johnny gaddar and then kaminey...

reply

<Spoilers>
I disagree where you don't tag sweety in "Kaminey" category. Her only intention is to marry Guddu and she uses all sort of tricks and kaminapanti. Be it emotional attyachar after she becomes pregnant. Or her lisping to get the love of Guddu. And as per my interpretation she tricked(removed the "Kamasutra" Condom packet) him to have unprotected sex so that she could become pregnant and marry him. Also there's a scene where she is crying and all but she has already told a pandit that she will be getting married that night itself.
Enough reasons for me to tag her in "kaminey" category.
</Spoilers>

Yes in JG everyone were Kamineys and it is a pretty nice movie but be it intensity or acting or direction the effect of kaminey(kaminywise) is much more.

Numbers of JG may be more but effect of JG is much more for me


"Ek Dil se dosti thi
Ye Huzoor bhi KAMINEY "


http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1274295/

reply