I don't know how the haters can hate this.

I thought it was great.
Yeah, it had problems like all movies do. The random images spliced all over the place was an odd choice, but it did make it unique and add a certain surrealism to the movie that most westerns don't have.
I thought the opening credits and some of the fight scenes also looked amateurish, but then again, this was a very low budget indie movie and it felt like most of the budget went towards great actors, costumes, and cinematography.
Some people seem to have a problem with the over the top dialogue and costumes, but it seems like that's what the movie is supposed to be. It's not a serious period piece, it's like a spaghetti western with modern sensibilities. Like the movies Robert Rodriguez and Quentin Tarantino make.
It's just supposed to be dumb fun.

"I was always a lover, despite the killing"
- Ransom Pride