Gulaal or Dev D


Which one did you like better?? (Assuming you liked Dev D that is..)

I personally prefer Gulaal over Dev D simply because of its more complex story and better, specifically of the four main characters in the movie.. Dev D was better visually but Gulaal scored better with me on the overall cinematic experience

reply

This is how I would rate Kashyap's movies :

Black Friday > Gulaal > No Smoking > Dev D.

And I thought Dev D was awesome...so the rest are just better than awesome :D

reply

I liked Dev.D much better--It was entirely about the characters. In Gulaal, I felt like the characters were second to just another crime story, and the love story ended up feeling kind of forced. I thought Gulaal just ended up feeling watered down. Rang de Basanti was also a much better crime/revolutionary film.

---
I know what gold does to men's souls.

reply

Both are brilliant movies but I'd rate Dev D just a notch above Gulaal...
The second half of Gulaal was not as powerful and that's where Dev D scores slightly above Gulaal...

reply

Gulaal all the way.

(\__/)
(='.'=)
(")_(")

reply

Gulaal any day

reply

Sorry Guys But You Guys haven't seen Paanch movie from Anuraag's List.That stands way above from all his movies :D

reply