Ashley is sexy.
Her face is cute (way better than Brookes) it's not a ten, but she is pretty damn hot. I was looking at the show (I don't watch that often.) and she has a amazing figure. She has those meaty thighs, and nice wide hips. I like that *beep*. her body for me is a ten, she has the perfect figure I like. About 5'6" nice legs, hips and thighs. I'm not a big boobs guy, so I don't care about that.
As for Brooke, she just ain't that cute for me. I used to think she was decent, but I just don't see it anymore. She has a nice chest, but that's it.
I don't watch the show that often, but from what I seen Brooke gets all the guys which is amazing to me.