Andrew Garfield

Having seen Boy A (and basically his entire filmography) I have to disagree completely. I actually found his charisma and talent to be the only thing that kept me watching. I was actually marveling 25 minutes in at how he comes across so much more masculine and confident in this versus ALL his other roles, which I found quite refreshing. Sometimes I think he deserves an Oscar for his facial expressions alone, much less his usual flawless delivery...but I digress.

I'll give the occasional mumbling, but for me that's more British films in general than Andrew. He doesn't tend to mumble when he's speaking without the British accent.

And from what I've seen in interviews/behind the scenes, he's actually quite light-hearted/goofy in real life. He sang the Bed Intruder song during an ABC Never Let Me Go interview for crying out loud.

Alas, this is but my opinion, and I respect yours. To each their own. That's the wonderful thing about film - so subjective.

Could not agree less with the OP. Garfield is sensational in the trilogy. Hugely charismatic, funny, charming, clueless, a danger to himself, but always compelling.

I think he did a great job in this series. I believed his performance, and was shocked at what could happen when people look the other way.

Your second life is never like your first. Sometimes it's even better