Going off to Italy like that?


Anyone think Charlie should have punished Bella with a scourging?

reply

Bella was 18-years-old, and legally could do as she pleased. In the book, Bella threatened to move out when Charlie tried to punish her by keeping her away from Edward. So he backed down on that point, and only grounded her. Bella put up with the grounding because she wanted to spend as much time with her Dad as she could before she left his life forever.

She most likely would have moved out if Charlie tried giving her a 'scourging.'






=========
http://tinyurl.com/TwilightSagaBoard
http://tinyurl.com/ProWhoosh

reply

No, he would just overpower her. Bella needs a scourging for being such a brat.

reply

She's an adult, and he's a cop. She is free to leave if she doesn't like his parenting, and he has no say in the matter.






=========
http://tinyurl.com/TwilightSagaBoard
http://tinyurl.com/ProWhoosh

reply

But he would just hold her down and start scourging. After that, it would be very difficult for her to leave as she would barely be able to walk.

reply

And he would be arrested for child abuse. Plus, Edward would come to her aid long before Charlie could do much damage.






=========
http://tinyurl.com/TwilightSagaBoard
http://tinyurl.com/ProWhoosh

reply

Why would he be arrested? Its just discipline. Bella lacks discipline and needs to be scourged badly. Edward could be arrested for interfering.

reply

Because scourging your daughter is abuse, and will get you arrested. Perhaps you should read:

Master of the Universe

by Snowqueens Icedragon
https://ohfifty.com/downloads/MOTU_w_Outtakes_Snowqueens_Icedragon_COMPLETE.pdf

It's the Twilight fanfic that was revamped into the Fifty Shades trilogy by E. L. James.

Snowqueens Icedragon = E. L. James






=========
http://tinyurl.com/TwilightSagaBoard
http://tinyurl.com/ProWhoosh

reply

Its completely legal. If anything, she would be arrested for trying to leave and be scourged by the police as punishment.

reply

Bella is 18. She is legally able to move in with the Cullens if she doesn't want to be scourged by Charlie. She could even move away with the Cullens and not inform Charlie, and he nor the police could do anything about it.






=========
http://tinyurl.com/TwilightSagaBoard
http://tinyurl.com/ProWhoosh

reply

No, she can't. She would be sent back to Charlie and scourged as punishment.

reply

 Edward would turn her and then she'd eat Charlie.






=========
http://tinyurl.com/TwilightSagaBoard
http://tinyurl.com/ProWhoosh

reply

And this is why Charlie should have started scourging Bella the second she arrived in the first film.

reply

Why would Charlie do that when he let his wife leave him with Bella in tow, and didn't do anything to stop her? He didn't even take her to court to get custody of Bella. Maybe Charlie is in need of a good scourging? 






=========
http://tinyurl.com/TwilightSagaBoard
http://tinyurl.com/ProWhoosh

reply

Is that now it happened? Also, Bella's mum should have scourged Bella.

reply