MovieChat Forums > 300: Rise of an Empire (2014) Discussion > How am I supposed to sympathize with the...

How am I supposed to sympathize with the Greeks?


Two words: Artemisia's childhood.

How am I supposed to sympathize with the Greeks?

What diversity used to mean: Diversity
What diversity now means: Fewer white people

reply

If you're going to hold one child's miserable life against an entire society then you're not going to able to not do the same with all of the past and present societies of man. As in every one of them has done and has had *beep* things done to it's citizens.

reply

Blunt, backhanded, but ultimately a good enough answer.

That didn't really happen to the real Artemisia, though.

What diversity used to mean: Diversity
What diversity now means: Fewer white people

reply

Might agree if she had been captured and tortured by a civilian that just happened to be a greek... But if you go with the story it was done by the Greek Hoplites so basically it was the army of the people of Greece... So frankly I was on her side - kill them all.

reply

Kill ALL Greeks because of the actions of a band of soldiers?

"Tahiti is not in Europe . . . I'm going to be SICK."

reply

There was no army of the people of Greece. The Greeks were not united under a single government which was why Themistocles was trying to unite them against Persia. Greece was divided into many city-states that shared certain cultural traits like language and religion. Yet at the same time could be very different culturally as evidenced by Sparta and Athens. She could blame the city-state the soldiers are from, but it is wrong to place everyone for at worst the crime of a single city-state.

reply

Because that was one band of soldiers from one army of a Greek City-state. There were dozens if not hundreds of city-states at the time each with their own military. The city-states all shared certain cultural traits like language and religion, but could also be very different as evidenced by Sparta and Athens. So you shouldn't blame the entire people for the actions of one group.

reply

You're not supposed to. Including this invented story naturally reduces the audience's sympathy for the Greeks, for men, and for whites (the rescuer being black).

#‎BringF4Home

reply

because persians were saints, right?
did you miss the part where the persians where ransacking athens and countless women were being.... "mistreated" barely noticeably on screen?.

reply