MovieChat Forums > Judas Kiss (2011) Discussion > Poorly acted, dumb story, waste of time.

Poorly acted, dumb story, waste of time.


If you read/scan the 19 reviews here, these critics mostly rave about the film. But if you check the voters, it averages under 5. Clearly, the film's crew/actors must be submitting such positive reviews, since I---and smany others--thought the film really sucked. I watched the DVD yesterday, and if you view the special features, the crew just raves abiout how "wonderful" the cast, crew and story are. You're wasting your time if you believe them.

reply

Clearly all the good reviews for this film were written by robots built by the cast and crew. It's the only possible explanation that someone might have an opinion that differs from yours. It's a conspiracy!

Some people like the movie, some don't. Get over it. And of course the extra features support the film. Welcome to reality. You'll enjoy your time here a lot more if you focus on things that make you happy.

reply

Sorry, my friend, one must focus on both the good and the bad, and this includes films, of which there are both. If you enjoyed this garbage, sobeit...it's your naive opinion. But if you saw more good movies you might be able to discriminate better between what is good and not-so-good. This movie's poor ratings speak for itself. Consensus is usually the best determination. Sorry to have offended you.

reply

Not conspiracy, but even a cursory check reveals that all but 3 of the 'reviews' are by folks who have never posted ANY other review at IMDb. In short the cast, crew and their families are responsible... of course since pretty much nobody outside the sad closed tiny circle of gay film festivals have ever seen or will ever see this film, it's not surprising there are so few real reviews....

reply

Sorry you waste your money in this piece of $hit...




Life is a Bitch, then you die!!!

reply

[deleted]

There are statistics on user voting. The teens and college age give it top scores. While the over 30 group score it around a five.

I would not blame the actors. They did a swell job compared to fan fiction video actors. If they had a higher budget they could call in more professional actors. Perhaps this movie is more of a stepping stone for experience.

The production\post production aspect of the film is done very well.

I still think your stressing out on the script and the story itself. Perhaps the Zen from Last Action Hero movie ... its the story-line and story telling that helps make a great film.

They marketed SyFy, time traveling, a do-over\fix it ... this is very superficial ... it brings down the quality of the script and story because its written like a fan-fic story. Very typically done in low budget formats.

Other syfy movies like back to the future forbid interacting with yourself ... but it is ok to interact in a non-confrontational .. more like a mentor would be a fine thing. The idea is for the young to be led down the path of doing the right thing. You can't make him drink in the truth. This is the mistake of the writer to choose this path. Its more like when Darth Vader says I'm your father. Well here we have to characters that says I'm you. Perhaps this is where we are his with stereotypical fan fic writing.

Yes, there are rather lame story line sales pitches on destiny, change your life, the setup of the characters in this manner really weakens the story almost to the point where the audience would walk out.

But the film is sugar coated with eye candy with with a porn star attributes.

There is one thing I think no one notice. The Dean could also be the producer Abby; the older self. Even thou she doesn't admit it but it seems logical in the structure of this film. Again this kind of setup is weak because we don't see the power of higher-self or twilight zone effect adsorbing us into this journey of self discovery.

Perhaps its worth 4bucks at Walmart but its price is very inflated at 18+ bucks everywhere else. Its a pity that the film wasn't put into theaters to see if it can earn its worth. Perhaps they hope the film will be picked up on the IFM channel where they can earn some additional income for making future films.

I feel that this film is just a stepping stone for the production company. If or when it recognizes the future challenges of getting into the main stream is to wait and see. If they continue the path of fan fic format then they will place themselves in a very exclusive and less profitable market.

Figure this. They have to sell like 50000 DVD plus the ticket sales to prove their film is worth to produce another. Otherwise the investors are in it for loyalty if they get their money back. If they can sell like 90000 dvd then perhaps they can have a promising future in making future productions.

reply

boyjames
If you want someone to believe you, learn to spell.
Having work on 4 films, I really enjoyed Judas Kiss.
Charlie was very good as I,ve learn to expect. You just didn't understand the film.

reply


"Having work on 4 films, I really enjoyed Judas Kiss.
Charlie was very good as I,ve learn to expect."

Have someone ELSE read that back to you, then think again about your "learn to spell" suggestion.

reply

> You're wasting your time if you believe them.

Actually, the movie is pretty good. Yeah, it's low budget and that's pretty obvious, but considering that, it actually works pretty well.

It's kind of rare that you see a gay movie that's a little more than just one long roll in the hay or a serious AIDS drama. This one had a bit of Sci-Fi to it that sort of kept you guessing.

--
What Would Jesus Do For A Klondike Bar (WWJDFAKB)?

reply

It might be better than typical gay porn but that doesn't make it good. The one thing I thought really was good was the relaxed physical intimacy going on between all the hot students. That says a lot because I almost always find sexual interactions in movies to be awkward, icky and unbelievable, but in this movie it was touching.

Unfortunately, I felt the movie as a whole was really cheesy and poorly done. Sure, it was low budget but a big budget wouldn't fix this story. Just look at the film within the film. Do you think you'd enjoy seeing the full thing? It's supposed to be this inspired work but it looks terrible.

reply