MovieChat Forums > Dorian Gray (2009) Discussion > Did Dorian come across as...

Did Dorian come across as...


Kind of a dick?

reply

Yeah, that was the point. Besides Basil's murder, however, I don't think he did anything particularly evil, just morally questionable.

"Why do you say this to me when you know I will kill you for it?"

reply

Well, I was aiming for understatement.

Did it seem like they were trying to play up a redemption angle at the end? I dont recall him being particularly penitent in the book

reply

I need to re-read the book, I can barely remember anything about it.

"Why do you say this to me when you know I will kill you for it?"

reply

There was an attempt at redemption at the end of the book too.

reply

At the end of the book, Dorian falls in love with a pretty young girl in some remote village, and determines to be a better person so he's worthy of her love. But in doing so he finds his painting is even more rotten and decayed than when he was just being evil which, to me, was a message about how there is no such thing as good and evil, only actions and consequences, and that Dorian, even when he was being good, was still being selfish.
In the end he still destroys his painting by his own hand but the movie made it much more of a confrontation, a realisation of 'I am a monster', whereas the book played it up more like a spur of the moment 'I can't take it anymore!' kind of action.
Look at it this way, in the movie Dorian locks himself in with the painting to force himself to destroy it, in the book he just goes to it and destroys it. As I said, in the book it's played up as very sudden and spontaneous, in the movie it's far more confrontational between Dorian and the painting.

reply


Kind of?

he was a major dick!



When there's no more room in hell, The dead will walk the earth...

reply

He did try to make up for his sins and redeem himself at the end of the book. He told Henry he had been seeing a young woman in a village outside of London who didn't know who he was, and then broke off the relationship before he could "ruin" her. I remember that. But, when he looked at the painting, hoping this good deed would affect it, it only looked worse.

reply

That's the whole point.

reply