Could Have Been so Much More Amazing


The premise of this project is really phenomenal. Discovery Channel offers to restore thousands of hours of footage for NASA, and they get a documentary out of it. It is sad, however, how little information and footage they included, and the major though insignificant events they did focus on.

In particular, the Shuttle episode was a huge disappointment. The first flights of women, African-Americans, other nationalities. There is amazing NASA-Shuttle flight footage out there on YouTube that doesn't even appear in this documentary.

No mention of Apollo-Soyuz and Shuttle-Mir dockings, construction of Shuttle. I understand that this was a "celebration" of NASA's finest moments (again, many left out) but the sacrifices of Apollo 1, Challenger, and Columbia needed to be told. In the case of Challenger, this documentary was the first time many people familiar with the disaster learned that it was not a true "explosion" but a structural break-up of the vehicle, and the astronauts survived the break-up of the shuttle and were more than likely alive until they hit the water.

Did we really need to see footage of Kennedy's Moon race challenge... AGAIN?

"From the Earth to the Moon" was a far better documentation (though somewhat dramatized) of Mercury through Apollo.

But in terms of Shuttle, so many amazing things happened during its flights that it is mind-boggling how much was left out. When this was produced, ISS was as large as a football field, but it is presented here as in early construction phases.

It WAS an interesting watch and I even bought the DVD for my collection, but couldn't and can't believe how much was not even covered.

reply

I would tend to agree with your opinion. I was expecting something much more comprehensive from this set, and felt disappointed after I had viewed it. In my opinion, the most comprehensive documentary on the space program is the 12 episode series, "Rocket Science" http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0428153/, produced in 2002 and televised on Discovery Channel. It goes way back and even includes early footage of Von Braun and Robert Goddard, and "The Right Stuff" years with coverage of the X1 program and interviews with Chuck Yeager and Scott Crossley.

It's difficult to find, but it's currently available from amazon.com.

reply

you are a moron. at that altitude the oxygen will be sucked out of your lungs. become unconscious and your blood would boil.you would live 15 seconds at most.

reply

I believe they could have easily made this a 10 to 12 part documentary series with all the missions that have taken place between the Americans and Soviets. That is the biggest problem I saw with this series. Not really any mention of what the Soviets accomplished. I also believe Discovery should have waited to air this until the shuttle program was completed all the way. Should have came out late this year or early 2012.

reply