MovieChat Forums > Üç Maymun (2008) Discussion > personally, found it unbearable

personally, found it unbearable


Film has a beautiful visual language, and I appreciated the long, introspective takes.

But "Three Monkeys" was simply unbearable to watch. Listening to people breathe for five minutes (through ADR no less) was like watching paint dry. And believe me, I've sat through many a film that required patience - "Begotten," "Dog Star Man," and "Platform" to name a few, all of which I loved immensely.

*slight spoiler ahead*

I felt I was being put on by the director - the film could have taken an interesting turn with the apparition of the lost child, which was an image lifted directly from the Guillermo Del Toro / J-Horror book of arthouse frights. The image was used for narrative purpose but it also came off as cheap thrills.

From that moment, I understand the inherent level of inner torture, but the characters were so incredibly unlikeable that I couldn't even try to walk a mile in their shoes. It doesn't mean that characters have to be amicable - I thought David Thewlis in Mike Leigh's "Naked" was an absolute monster, but I was fascinated by him. The characters in "Three Monkeys" always keep you at arm's distance, which is immensely frustrating. And if that's the point, then I don't translate that to an engaging film experience.

I really don't get the praise that is being bestowed upon this film. I give it top praise for its cinematography, but other than that I found it to be an exercise in banal arthouse indulgence.

"We can never achieve peace by killing each other's children."

reply

Its because of Turkish directors and writers. They think they know how to make film, thats why I dont pay to see Turkish movies at theaters, they are all eventually broadcasted on TV.

Happy endings are just stories that haven't finished yet

reply

Thanks for the great post.

It's so hard to be objective with film analysis. At the end of the day it's a matter of taste. But I think you articulated so well why not everyone who's into quality cinema will like this.

I think the directors ego is BIG. I think he is trying to make GREAT cinema with this film. A bit like P.T.Anderson with There Will Be Blood. Yawn.

reply