Will anyone admit they didn't know?

I seriously had no idea it was Henry. I was thinking maybe Cal or Jimmy at some parts.

I pretty much thought it was Jimmy most of the way through, but then when they said it could be Jimmy I was like "Oh, well then I guess it can't be Jimmy. It is probably Henry". So I figured it out the episode before we found out it was Henry. I pretty much had Henry as a "possible" suspect in my mind since Trish's almost drowning scene (and even more so after JD's death), but it was really a minor suspicion until the end.

I first suspected Cal hard core for the first few episodes, then Jimmy until the "oh look at Jimmy's mugshot" scene, then it was Henry for the last 3. And there was a moment where I thought it could be Abby, but that lasted for like 10 seconds.

I knew it was henry because I spoiled myself but at first I thought it was either Trish or Jimmy.

No one writes songs about the ones that come easy
http://bit.ly/aMmHyS

I started having suspicions around the time Beth was murdered, but my jaw dropped when it was finally shown, yeah.

My top 3 suspects were Shea, Sully, and Henry. I thought Henry was too obvious (scratches, blood on hands, acts of violence toward Shane, and so on). His always being around Abby I thought was because he really just loved Abby more than Trish, not that they were related or anything like that (in a sick way like was revealed). I thought that either Shea (she is pretty cold you have to admit, in parts of the series) could've offed family members for an inheritance, and then Richard was acting suspicious before he died, and then with her trying to silence everyone questioning Madison made me suspect her more. But, then I thought maybe Sully because he looked more like Wakefield (possibly his son?) and maybe his accomplice. He also would've been far less suspect and made for a more unpredictable ending. Anyway, but I never would've guessed the whole half brother/sister thing.

Happily; I didn't know. Henry was a good candidate, since he knew all the victims and had organized the Harper's Island trip, but he didn't seem to have a motive. I had some issues with the series, but I thought the identity twist was very well done.

Maybe the biggest problem with Henry as the killer would be when he killed his brother; all J.D. would have had to say before expiring was "It was Henry." Instead, he says, "It's all about you, Abby." That's hard to understand.

As for other thoughts, I was pretty sure it wasn't Jimmy, since the first victim was an obscure relative of Trish's who was murdered before leaving for the Island, but there were doubts about everyone. I guess Sully seemed like a good candidate, a sturdy, capable misanthrope, but he seemed to come around late. The Sheriff was a good candidate early, but became less likely after he was hanged. Shea was an interesting option, since her daughter was such a creepshow, but she didn't seem strong enough. I was so sure it wasn't Chloe that I thought it might be Chloe. But, really, for me Sully and the Sheriff were the best candidates early.

I thought they went out of their way to make us think it was Jimmy or the Sherriff, even before all the suspicions from the rest of the characters. At first I thought it might've been Chloe, just because they emphasised why someone like her would go out with someone like Cal. Then I changed to Danny for a long while, as he was the one that seemed to have no backstory, or the quiet one in the background so to speak. And then at the end when it had to be Sully or Henry because of Wakefield mentioning his 'son', of course it was going to be Henry!

Nearly any guess is a good one right at the start though. Although anyone who thought it might've been Hunter Jennings probably hasn't seen enough of these whodunnits LOL.

I was pretty much certain it was Jimmy!
Henry was just like... wow!

... what do you say to that broccoli ... stop mocking me ...